Disturbing Black Ops emblems embarrass the entire game community

Chas_profile
Sunday, January 09, 2011

"Online Interactions Not Rated by the ESRB."

I never put much thought into that phrase until I saw how depraved the Call of Duty: Black Ops community can be. In the last week, I've seen user-made gun emblems showing people having sex with animals (and vice-versa), KKK members lynching black men in a tree, a woman violating herself with a beer bottle, and countless instances of masturbation and drug use (occasionally combined into the same image).

Black Ops

When I originally bought Black Ops, I noticed a woman and her son (who looked no older than 13) were buying the same game and a PlayStation 3. Yes, it's a mature-rated title, but if Black Ops caught me off guard, I imagine that mom will auction the PS3 on eBay once she recovers from the shock of seeing what her son's new online friends created.

It's disappointing to see members of the community conducting themselves online in the most vulgar ways possible when society seems to be accepting video games more and more each year. Black Ops in particular seems to draw out the worst of the worst by allowing them to customize the emblems that represent their profiles. I doubt parents who felt their children were mature enough to handle the game's violence ever expected its online community included fans of rape, racial bigotry and bestiality.

 

To be fair, the majority of players don't have offensive emblems. Some users have actually made really clever use of Black Ops' limited selection of tools to recreate famous characters. I'm always stunned when I see Futurama's Dr. Zoidberg, the kids from South Park, pretty much everyone from the Mario series, and plenty of other pop-culture icons. Less artistic players like myself just stick with the stock images of guns and skulls, but the more creative community members really exemplify what developer Treyarch had in mind when it came up with the feature. Others, however, squander their time and talent by combining images in crude and superficial ways to make sick jokes with no punchline. Treyarch has provided an easy option to report offensive emblems and has banned players for recreating inappropriate images like the Nazi flag, but you can still stumble across these pictures far too often nearly two months after the game's release.

Black Ops

What's more bothersome is that people choose to represent themselves similarly on every online game and not just Black Ops. I've encountered players with ridiculous gamertags describing their genitalia (Long_Schlong) and racial prejudices (Fu_ck Nig_gers). Rather than a crude image found in one game, though, these names follow and represent players everywhere on their console. I can't imagine accepting a friend request from OBAMAKILLER480, but it's unfathomable that someone would even take the time to register such a name. What does it say about a person when they choose to be known for something so vile?

Forget about video games desensitizing children to violence. When people choose to be identified by their intolerance and sick sense of humor, and we simply accept it as part of the community, it's hard to argue that we're not becoming apathetic toward such despicable behavior.

Black Ops

It's frustrating when those who have never stepped foot inside the video-game community see nothing but violence from the distance, but I hope for the industry's sake that those people never take a closer look. What they find in communities like Black Ops' will only serve to embarrass and harm the medium's reputation for a long time to come. Do yourself a favor and report every offensive emblem you see (and report those inappropriate usernames/gamertags while you're at it). Otherwise, you're only contributing to a problem that's waiting to blow up in our faces.

 
Problem? Report this post
CHAS GUIDRY'S SPONSOR
Comments (31)
Phantom
January 09, 2011

This is what happens when you combine anonymity and immaturity. Most of the assholes with these emblems probably aren't KKK members (though they're obviously racist); they just think it's funny that they can make such scandalous pictures. And it's not.

But as a former "Naked School Boy" on Xbox Live, I can't condemn ALL immature gamertags (just the ones that stink of bigotry). After all, playing with a "Fat Black Penus" [sic] in Halo 2 was a fun, gratifying experience.

36970_440604814609_500264609_5862488_5061095_n
January 09, 2011

I feel like there are two groups of communities. There are the "underground" who are people like you and me that appreciate the opportunity we have to interact with fellow gamers without abusing the privilege. Then there are the public facing individuals who abuse the system every chance they get. Unfortunately for us the public facing people far outnumber the underground. Their terrible acts aren't only encountered in multiplayer games, but in forums as well.

Short of implementing a community version of the TSA there isn't much we can do. They will always exist. It's up to us to implement a change in how the world perceives us as a whole.

Channel5
January 09, 2011

I think it's more for shock value. If these images get someone to call out the gaming industry on being a racist/sexist/homophobic freak show then so be it. Not like it would be hard to make a case with or without the Black Ops emblems.

I disagree with it damaging the gaming industries reputation. Black Ops is the best selling game. It'll only increase sales and build a buzz for the next Call of Duty.

Chas_profile
January 09, 2011

Don't you think these images being attached to such a huge seller only makes us look worse? People don't look at games as say "Wow, they make a lot of money." They saw "Wow, that's violent!" or "That's vulgar!" The fact that it's part of such a popular game just makes it worse because it gets that much more exposure.

N752290354_2283
January 09, 2011

In the time I've played I haven't seen anything quite as offensive as the images you posted. But I do recall when I first got into the multiplayer of Black Ops I quickly saw things like a Bunny with a giant penis and similar vulgar things. For that sort of thing I just kind of sigh at how immature alot of gamers/people are. I'm not prude but I really don't find that kind of humour funny, putting a giant dick on something isn't about to make me laugh.

That people have escalated to this sort of horrible imagery is really disappointing and kind of depressing. I always go out of my way to report anyone who has an offensive gamertag or I hear saying something especially horrible of bigoted. For what little it can do, I do wish this sort of tihng could be stamped out easily it really does bring down an otherwise great experience.

Channel5
January 09, 2011

@Chas No. I think the best selling game should attract the most erratic behavior from the people who play it. The more people in any given situation the more likely your going to find vulgarity.  If these images were in a game like Tony Hawk's Shred then I'd think we have a problem.

The people that say "Wow, that's violent!" aren't the ones that are running to the store to buy a copy of the game before it's pulled off the shelf. They're the ones that look like idiots standing outside of Gamestop with picket signs.

You can argue that Black Ops allows you to kill these bigots. Thus making these people an inspiration to increase your skills to fight against bigotry.

Chas_profile
January 09, 2011

Do you think the people on the outside looking in really care that the racists and homophobes are inspiring us to play better? They'll just see the vulgarity and assume we're playing along with them, which we are.

I understand your point that there's a greater chance of encountering these people in such a popular game, but that's also a problem when big games like this break into mainstream culture more and more each year.

Me_001
January 09, 2011

This is sad. The deviant minority brings shame to the decent majority. It makes the industry an even taller lightning rod for bad publicity. Also, it is distasteful and...simply wrong. 

Channel5
January 09, 2011

@Chas I think these people are a small minority, and probably wont have a great impact on damaging the reputation of videogames. Jack Thompson tried to fight against violence in videogames, and he wasn't so successful.

Get rid of all of the offensive images and usernames, and you'll still have people calling me a "F*ggot" or "Ni**er" through their mics. The best thing these concerned people can do is not buy the game. Call of Duty has too big of a following of people who already know how ridiculous others can be online.

Chas_profile
January 09, 2011

See, that's the problem right there. "Concerned people"? It should bother you that people who choose to be overly rude, perverted, disgusting, etc. online, no matter how few they may be, can earn such a reputation yet people simply choose not to be concerned with it. Don't you think that's a sign that these people are desensitizing us to hurtful words and stereotypes to the point that it's okay for them to do it?

Channel5
January 09, 2011

pfft no. Growing up gay and black in America I've heard it all from people I've met in real life. I'm not going to let some immature a**holes bring me down because they said or did something offensive in a videogame. I actually feel sorry for the people who hide behind a videogame to show who they really are.

Chas_profile
January 09, 2011

Well, it's great that you don't let it bother you personally, but I'd still prefer it if my preferred medium wasn't dragged down by the occasional idiots who immediately jump to create images of animal sex or lynchings when given the opportunity to express themselves.

Shoe_headshot_-_square
January 09, 2011

I see Chas's point. I haven't seen these types of emblems so much in Black Ops, but I do try to report offensive Gamertags wheneve I see 'em. I don't like that people don't respect my hobby, and this stuff doesn't help. It's quite embarrassing.

Picture_002
January 09, 2011

I'm inclined to side with Errol on this. Yes I'd love to be rid of the racism, sexism and bigotry as much as anyone. I'd just like that gone from life, gaming's the least of my concerns fo that. But like it or not, this is the residual impact of the industry's growth. Becoming mainstream and welcoming in the masses means bringing in the ignorant and undesirable as well unfortunately. This doesn't particularly "embarrass" or "shock" me as a gamer; this is part of the world I've seen well before Call of Duty existed. I get a lot more embarrassed at how many gamers live in denial in this segment of the community when bigotry in the community is brought up as an issue. Yes, this sort of thing needs to be dealt with and condemned but that it often has to get to something this graphic for gamers to get embarrassed enough to do so. Let be honest, if it weren't connected to an incredibly high profile game, there probably isn't an article for me to comment on.

I'm beyond the obsessing overhow the mainstream media perceives gamers. I live securely believing there's a segment of the population that just flat out will never like gamers or look on them favorably. There's nothing that gamers can clean up nor hide that will earn their validation. And if there's a person out there concerned about this primarily for fears of outside perceptions, I question their motivation.

I spend a lot more time worrying about the actual games that pop up from those ideologies; the Ethnic Cleansings, Border Patrols, Ghetto Blasters and Shoot the F****s that act as recruitment and propaganda tools for movements that both the mainstream media and games press brush completely under the rug. The sick gun emblems and gamertags are a problem, uncomfortable and unwelcome. But I wonder if they are as impactful per word count as the games rarely discussed.

Snapshot_20100211_14
January 09, 2011
See, I kind of completely disagree. I actually laughed out loud at the second picture, not because of the content persé, but because someone went through that much effort to make it. I am one of those people who reports gamertags, but creative imagery isn't going to make me cry about it. Honestly, you could give people three shapes and they'd still find a way to make something offensive. Don't blame the game for that. Also, the reason we ignore it isn't to make it seem okay. Most people like that do it strictly to get a rise out of someone it offends. By not responding, you take away their power. Think of it as the same way that blacks started calling each other the n-word to take the power of it away.
Default_picture
January 10, 2011

See I laugh at the pictures, some because there funny, and others because of the creators ignorance. The pictures I make are actually creative along with my friends we put time into our emblems

Img_20100902_162803
January 10, 2011
Hate speech in the 21st century. The publisher should be more proactive in banning the users who create these images.
Default_picture
January 10, 2011

plus, keep in mind that it's a rated M game, you know, for mature audiences. this isn't something to take seriously. im not a racist, and i think these pics are funny. i personally can't stand the penis pics, but i dont bitch about it. so because this is a rated-M game, it'll have images controversial, especially user-created ones. but don't forget that this game has swastikas too, mw2 has the No-Russian level, mw1 shows terrorists executing civilians, its just ironic to me that ppl make a big deal out of emblems, and yet, they're okay with what's in the videogame. sure, what's in the game is part of the story- part of the imagery. but if an emblem is such a big deal, then don't play the game

In this text, "It's frustrating when those who have never stepped foot inside the video-game community see nothing but violence from the distance... communities like Black Ops' will only serve to embarrass and harm the medium's reputation for a long time to come," you see, this is where I have to stop you. This just sounds pro-Jack Thompson. Besides, how can it be frustrating to see nothing but violence at a distance from another person's viewpoint, are you implying games should be less violent too? I also don't know what you mean by the medium's reputation, since gaming isn't really reported on the news, except through controversies. Even then, a non-gamer would not care about gaming, gaming news, or aspects about gaming, especially violence or sex.

Long story short, it's not a big deal.

"Otherwise, you're only contributing to a problem that's waiting to blow up in our faces." =/ really? You're going to insult the reader too?

Default_picture
January 10, 2011

"emblems showing people having sex with animals (and vice-versa), KKK members lynching black men in a tree, a woman violating herself with a beer bottle, and countless instances of masturbation and drug use (occasionally combined into the same image)."

 

...I just have an Awesome Face. >_>

:P

Chas_profile
January 10, 2011

Anthony: How can you even compare swastikas and No Russian in the campaigns to these emblems?

And please don't put words in my mouth. You say I sound pro-Jack Thompson when I mention how frustrating it is that people still try to link violence to video games. My point was that, while violence in games has gotten loads of attention, the way people spew (and tolerate) hate online is an ACTUAL problem. These people have convinced those unfamiliar with games that they're more graphic and influential than they really are in terms of violence. I'd hate to see them add fuel to the fire with a look at these depraved emblems and gamertags. The fact that the game is rated M means nothing. Kids will play it. Everyone knew that long before the game was released.

Redorbluepill_
January 10, 2011

The images are just the next rung in the ladder.  Even if the offending parties are few, and do not represent the gaming community as a whole, they are MUCH more vocal and now visual.  I might be shocked by this artwork if I didn't already listen to foul mouthed, racist, sexist, homophobes, on PSN and LIVE, all the time.  The internet is worse than alcohol in they way it empowers people to "express" things that would normally be afraid to say in person,  for fear of the social repercussions.  I guess that's what it really boils down to.  Who spends all that time and creative energy, constructing a emblem of a Klan member with a lynching rope?  The same person who is overly aggressive and insulting to people over a headset because they believe another player to be, black, or jewish, or gay, or (gasp!) a girl. (God help all those black, jewish, gay, girl gamers out there! ) 
These people are cowards.  They lurk in the shadows of internet anonymity and "fire" insults behind uninspired gamer-tags.  I want to believe that these people are a very loud and annoying, but tiny section of the gaming populace.  They are definitely the reason I use my ear piece sparingly, if at all. I tune them out, not out of fear, or because I'm too sensitive, but because I don't have time for it.  I am here to play games, and enjoy myself.  I choose not to listen to three guys verbally sexual assault the only girl gamer in the room, or hear two people screaming at each other about who could "really" beat the other in a physical altercation, or be subjected to a room where everyone is calling each other every type of racist, gay slur they can remember.  I just want to play a game like Joshua.
 

Default_picture
January 11, 2011

The problem with censorship is simply that some people will find things insulting that most do not.  As a society we can't kowtow to people every little wim.  I'm not saying I agree with what people are doing, but what is the logical conclusion to censorship?  

Also, I can't help but think how easy it is for people to assign and evil label to other people.  I hate the haters, so I don't interact with these folks.  A system that places all of them together in the same server disables these people from doing what is essentially their intended purpose, to offend.

And if it's not their intended purpose, then putting them into servers where they can speak their mind (so to speak) is what will make them happiest.

Default_picture
January 11, 2011

Well said. The community is what we make it; if the negative examples outweigh the positive ones, we have nobody else to blame.

I have a few articles on this topic, both on exactly how to report emblems (though I'm betting everybody here can figure it out) and what happens when you do: 

http://oneofswords.com/2010/11/cod-black-ops-and-the-nasty-emblems/

http://oneofswords.com/2010/11/nasty-black-ops-emblems-2-what-happens/

Picture_002
January 11, 2011

There's a dramatic difference from full blown, threat-to-all-our-civil-liberties censorship and certain things being completely unwelcome in certain spaces. And I'm sorry but if a person of a certain age can't discern the image of a Klansman burning and lynching people as at the very least a potentionally problematic image, I'll go on a imb and guess their judgement probably lends them to bigger problems than someone advocating the ban-hammer in on online community.

For as much as certain people moan about censorship like articles or discussions like this mark the impending coming of 1984, the fact of the matter is most places aren't nor have even been complete free speech zones. Certain speech and express can get you kicked out of a restuarant, public transportation, a campus, online forums like this one, an office or even a place as private one's own parent's place. I'd venture to say the overwhleming majority of people don't have confusion over what draws that sort of consequence nor that the stuff pictured above and discussed in this article might draw negative feedback.

Seriously, freedom of speech doesn't mean right to platform nor protection from ridicule and criticism. It never ceases to amaze me how many people appear oblivious to that.

Default_picture
November 26, 2011

well think of it this way. If i kicked your ass on Call of duty then called you a fucking basement dwelling N word would you not report me? Sa you didnt and i started sending you racial messages, would you not block me? OH but blocking counts as censorship. Then you'd have two options. Start a new account or allow me to harass you. 

Picture_002
November 26, 2011

Uhhh....what?

Pict0079-web
November 26, 2011

...Just nod your head. I'm sure that he hasn't even read the Bitmob article about Xbox Live accounts getting banned.

Default_picture
November 27, 2011

luckly i dont play xbox anyway what im mearly stating is that although people dont have the riht to trample on "freedom of speech" but when someone uses that concept to emotionally or even mentally harm an individual thats when the first amendment right starts getting abused and we make that excuse as justification to say and do as we please without the fear of someone saying we cant.

Picture_002
November 27, 2011

Okay, thanks for clearing that up a bit. 

When I made that closing comment above, it was in reference to all the people that moan and complain about being censored when they say or do something they know full well is going to be inflammatory and offensive. Whether it stuff like this, someone pulling a Don Imus, or some politician getting themselves in hot water, or just flat out some of the people I've seen here or elsewhere trying to advocate "absolute free speech; they are usually in truth advocating freedom from consequence and being called out on their B.S. Hence while so often in discussions similiar to this, that side of it pulls out the First Ammedment even though 90% of the time they aren't talking about a situation in which the it actually applies; government suppression of speech. They are often just grasping at any excuse they can pull find to not be called racists, sexists, bigots or some other variation of asshole.

Default_picture
November 26, 2011

I've noticed a lot of this happening although i have to say the company shouldnt be embarresed rather discussed with the immature little shits that get on. Every time i play black ops i ALWAYS EVERYDAY hear people on their mics calling each other the N word and yelling at others for no reason. My user name is TheEmoNoctis. My score card says i have triple the kills to deaths since i started playing (this is to say im a good player) and after ive beaten people, people get on their mics and call me names like "fagget ass emo" or ask if i cut and to go kill myself and such. People online are just immature and stupid and the company is not to blame its those assholes with poor judgement and not enough to do. I report people all the time for their emblems. Ive even seen one with a guys genitals being shoved into a horses ass and its disgusting. Although i dont report people for the swaztica because that feeds into political beliefs. If the company allows for the Anarchy symbol then the swazitca shouldnt be banned. Although im offended by it. same goes for the pentagram. If the company allows the cross why not the pentagram. The KKK emblem is common too but im pretty sure people do that to be stupid. It's ppl like this that are gonna make infinity ward stop letting us make our own emblems. Some people ive talked to say that they shouldnt get reported for an offensive tag or emblem because it describes them but there is a place for everything and this is not one of them. The online community is full of different races, sexualities, religion, and taste so people need to stop being immature little shits and have some god damn desency.

Default_picture
November 26, 2011

People online need to treat each other as if they were their best friend. Im pretty sure that you wouldnt play call of duty with your black friend with a KKK clan tag.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.