Golf Logic vs. Game Logic

Default_picture
Friday, June 26, 2009

Editor's Note: I love playing golf with my father and my brother. I wish they would play Tiger Woods PGA Tour with me -- then maybe I could use my superior knowledge of videogame logic to beat them at some form of golf for the first time in more than two decades! Reid brings up a valid point; golf on the links is different than golf on a console. -Jason


Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10

My father loves to play golf. He's been playing since he was in high school. Unfortunately, actually going out to play is becoming harder and harder to do thanks to time constraints and financial issues. So for Father's Day, my siblings and I got him Tiger Woods PGA Tour 10 for Wii (with Wii Motion Plus). My father was pretty excited about the gift, so we both drove to his house and started playing.

First off, thank you, EA, for allowing players to use the same Wii Remote when playing golf and disc golf. Allowing all players to use one Wii Motion Plus without having to trust the consumer to know to buy more is a genius move.

One of the key features of the Wii Motion Plus is that it will give a more 1:1 experience than the original Wii-mote. Tiger Woods PGA Tour has been boasting that with Wii Motion Plus, every flaw in your game will be re-created accurately. Unfortunately for long time golfers -- and new-time gamers -- this is not the case for the entire experience. My father has a very weird golf swing; he deliberately adds a lot of draw to his shots and aims to the right to compensate. The game doesn't read this action very well, so I tend to have better accuracy than him. He also knows how to read greens and elevation very well, but Tiger Woods PGA Tour does not. My father frequently overanalyzes a shot and completely screws it up because the game is not like real golf.

 

On the other hand, this game is very easy for me. Like all good golf games, Tiger Woods PGA Tour gives you an abundance of information before you take your swing. Not only does it show you where you are aiming, it also tells you how much power you need, wind speed and direction, how much of the surface restricts your shot, and exact elevation. Using all of this information, I can tell what the game wants me to do to make a good shot. This is where I think the game fails on bringing in casual gamers.

Tiger Woods PGA Tour relies too much on videogame logic and math instead of actual golf logic. This means that someone who has played games all of their life and can do quick math in their head will always beat someone who has only played real golf all of their life. While this is true in almost every other videogame out there, that's not what the marketing for this game wants you to believe.

I’ve only played a few hours so far, and I’m really enjoying it. As we play more and more of the game, my father's starting to learn how to play the "videogame" version of golf and is getting better, too. I’ll post a more in-depth review in the future after I have more time with the title.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (4)
Default_picture
June 27, 2009
Nice write- up, but I will still say I am not a gopher though.
Alg_halo-reach-beta
June 27, 2009
I agree with that dude haha. Sadly i'm just going to buy Wii Motion Plus Separately (not a golf fan)
Jason_wilson
June 28, 2009
As a longtime golfer, I've never been able to get into videogame golf until after tweaking my back in a car accident. It now hurts to swing. But it doesn't hurt to swing in Tiger Woods (at least on the PS3). While some of the basic concepts of golf do apply to the series, you must use them within a game context. No wonder I stink.
Default_picture
June 30, 2009
I just got this game over the weekend, so it's nice to see a perspective from someone who has actually played Golf. I had a feeling it wasn't accurate, but it's still pretty fun. It's certainly the best golf game I've played so far, and disc golf is a lot of fun (but of course that's different from the real thing too). Sometime, I'm thinking about renting EA's new tennis game and see how it performs with Wii Motion Plus, because I actually used to play tennis quite a bit.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.