Separator

My Four-Year-Old Son Plays Grand Theft Auto

Headshot
Saturday, June 05, 2010
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Jay Henningsen

I have to profess that I experienced some initial shock upon reading the headline of this article, but I think I should not comment further and just let you folks experience this tale for yourselves. I honestly don't think you'll be disappointed.

At the very impressionable age of four, my son loved Grand Theft Auto. More specifically, the version he played was the Hot Coffee-moddable San Andreas. Before Child Protective Services bestows upon me the prestigious honor of father of the year, allow me to explain. 

Hot CoffeeGaming has been a part of my son's life since the moment he was born, so I was not surprised when he showed an interest in video games as early as the age of two. I started him off where I began my gaming career: the original Nintendo Entertainment System. He built up his hand-eye coordination and took the bridge out from under Bowser in no time. Then one day, he got a glimpse of me playing Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas and asked if he could play. What happened next was quite the eye-opener.

With a DualShock controller in hand, he started to press each button individually as he tried to figure out what their functions were. Soon he asked, “How do I get in a car?” I pointed and told him, “The one with the green triangle on it.” 

I egged him on to take the car in front of him which was waiting at the red light. He quickly looked up at me with disgust and refused, stating that the car was already owned by the person driving it. His response absolutely amazed me, so I decided to sit back and observe how he chose to interact with this highly controversial game without the aid of a rotten-minded adult.

 

He finally entered an unoccupied car and began driving. He was very mindful of the other cars and pedestrians. He didn't know the rules of the road, so he ran red lights and turned down one-way streets in the wrong direction. However, he did stop at intersections if a group of cars were gathered waiting for the light to turn green. 

At one such intersection, he attempted to brake, but he was traveling too fast. Instead of plowing into the rear of the car ahead of him, he swerved to the right and popped up onto the sidewalk. In doing so, he accidently ran over a woman walking toward his oncoming car. He was incredibly ashamed of himself and profusely apologized.

“It’s OK. It’s only a game. It’s not real,” I reassured him. After a few minutes of me explaining the difference between a game and real life, he felt comfortable enough to continue playing. 

San Andreas Cop


Only seconds later, he witnessed a policeman jump out of his patrol car to pursue a criminal of San Andreas. His eyes lit up as he asked if he could drive the police car. I reminded him that it was only a game, and it was fine to take the car. As he drove the squad car, I pressed L3 to turn on the lights and siren. He asked very excitedly if he could get the bad guys, too. With a huge smile, I pressed R3 to initiate the Vigilante Missions. It was as if his imagination had come to life. He was taking down delinquents left and right. As expected, the dangerous work of an officer brought an ambulance. 

At this point my son was familiar with the game’s mechanics and hopped into the ambulance. As he put the crime fighting behind him, he wondered out loud if it were possible to take people to the hospital. I instructed him to press R3, and he was off to save a few lives. He was having a blast racing from point to point, picking up people in need, and then speeding off to Las Venturas Hospital. During one of his life-saving adventures, he passed a fire house with a big, red, shiny fire truck parked out front. He didn't want to let his passengers down, so he took them to the hospital and then asked if I could guide him back to the fire truck.

Getting behind the driver’s seat of the fire truck awarded him with the most fun he had while playing Grand Theft Auto. With sirens blaring, he chased down the first red dot on the map. As he approached a car engulfed in flames, he began showering it with the truck’s water cannon. Fire after fire, he extinguished them all.

Joe Lieberman's worst nightmare.

In all his time with Grand Theft Auto, my son never once encountered any of the controversy surrounding this notorious title. He didn’t beat any hookers with a baseball bat. He didn’t deal drugs. He didn’t go on a murderous rampage. He certainly never once had a cup of hot coffee. He didn't avoid these things because I told him he couldn't try them; it just never occurred to him to commit these acts in the first place. 

The ESRB rating found on every box is a great tool for parents who are not familiar with games and their content, but I strongly disagree with using them as tools to raise our kids. Every child is different, and, as parents, it is our responsibility to cater to their individual needs. I understand not every kid is like mine, so I wouldn’t recommend that everyone allow their children to play Grand Theft Auto. But I would recommend that you listen and pay attention to your little ones to determine what they are capable of handling and what they are not ready for yet. They might even surprise you and find the light in something thought to have been so dark.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (33)
Twit
June 03, 2010

HA. It's so easy to forget about those missions. Guess the media wouldn't find them very news worthy for broadcast.

Nice piece!

Pshades-s
June 03, 2010

Great, great story. I hope my son and I can share a moment like this once he's old enough to play games. And thanks for reminding me of the fun I had playing taxi driver, ambulance driver, vigilante and firefighter in the older GTA games. One huge reason I found GTAIV so empty was because those options were unceremoniously removed. Indeed, at the start of that game there's nothing to do BUT break the law.

Jayhenningsen
June 05, 2010

Matthew - It looks like this is the first article you published at Bitmob. I have to say, I think this is an excellent start, and I look forward to your future work. Thanks for making me see Grand Theft Auto in a completely different light.

Default_picture
June 05, 2010

I had a similar reaction playing games like that with my son.  While I didn't actually let him play GTA to see how he would have played the game, I'm sure he would have done something similar.   When he was real little, he was playing Simpson's Road Rage and just liked driving around in the cars. 

One of the great things was when I would want to play a Call of Duty title.. and my son said that I shouldn't because it had "too many guns".. pushing me instead to play other games.  On the contrary, one of his favorite titles to play is the Halo series.  The big distinction he has draw was that he's not shooting people, he's defending everyone from the aliens.    Being 8, I'm still surprised even halo takes a back seat on a lot of occasions to tactical games such as Command and Conquer and Advance Wars. 

While he has access and plays a lot of these violent games.. I've often found him gravitating toward Banjo and Kazooie, Viva Pinata, and Pokemon.  Bottom line is that kids play for the fun of it.  Most of them if raised right knows the difference between right and wrong.  They also will play games devoid of violence if left to their own devices.  It isn't games that make kids violent, it is the lack of parenting and the rest of society's acceptance of violent behavior.

Photo-3
June 05, 2010

I like how you don't use video games as a baby sitter for your son.

Headshot
June 05, 2010

Thank you for all the great feedback! Jay, I too am very surprised my first article made it to the front page. I have a couple ideas floating around my head for my next article.

Shoe_headshot_-_square
June 05, 2010

Fantastic story! Love seeing this perspective from a four-year-old's eyes.

100media_imag0065
June 06, 2010

Great read. That brought a big smile to my face. He sounds like a great kid.

Default_picture
June 06, 2010

Cool kid.

Lance_darnell
June 06, 2010

Doesn't this mean that only evil people do evil things in GTA?

Fitocrop
June 06, 2010

This was such a great read, Matthew!

It's frightening how our perspective of humanity changes so much as we get older -- so much that we forget how to see the potential of good in a lot of things.

I really like that last line you wrote about children:

"They might even surprise you and find the light in something thought to have been so dark."

Default_picture
June 06, 2010

Yeah that was fantastic. I wasn't expecting that at all when I read the article title. Way to suck me in! ;)

Default_picture
June 08, 2010

@Lance Darnell: "Doesn't this mean that only evil people do evil things in GTA?"

 

My daughter played Black and White and B&W 2 from age 9 (now 13).  I knew she would end up being an evil character, although I can't bring myself to do anything "bad" in game. I also know that our other daughter will be more like me and stick to the "good" side.

 

Not sure why really.

Default_picture
June 09, 2010

Excellent article, and not what I was expecting!

Jason_wilson
June 09, 2010

This makes me want to play GTA as a fireman. 

Default_picture
June 09, 2010

Great article, very thought provoking. You sound like a 5-star parent!

It was brought up in a reader's feedback section UK Metro (http://www.metro.co.uk/tech/830132-games-inbox-blur-kart-bad-parents-and-the-best-of-the-playstation-2). Their response? "It makes us think being a parent should require a license."

*Sigh* And it makes me think that some people are better at jumping to conclusions than they are at reading.

Default_picture
June 09, 2010

That was such a great article that, catching it on Gamespy, i came right to the source and registered just so i can leave a comment! Talk about great parenting. It is pretty amazing how kids know almost by instinct right or wrong, alot of it is picked up by the parents, which, from what i just read, that boy is being brought up by some pretty great ones. Kudos to a great gaming Father and son team!

Default_picture
June 10, 2010

I wish every kid would be like this one.

Default_picture
June 10, 2010

Giving a kid Grand Theft Auto is no different than giving them a toy gun and a powerwheels. Are some kids going to run over barbies and pretend to steel the car from each other? Sure. Is that going to do mental damage to them? Probably not.

Teaching kids the difference between pretend and reality is the key. The ESRB raitings are for people who want to take the easy way out and just keep their kids in a bubble insetead of actually parenting.

Default_picture
June 10, 2010

A story like this almost regains my faith in humanity, good for you sir

0827102146-01
June 11, 2010

Great job, Dad! Innocence in today's society shines much brighter for us, the older we get.

Has your son's insights changed your philosophy toward gaming?

Headshot
June 11, 2010

@Cassandra, 

I found it very interesting that a child and an adult could look at the exact same thing and have two totally different perspectives.

Myself, I was never really censored as a child. I watched, listened to, and played anything I wanted. As an eight-year-old by the end of the 1980s, Andrew Dice Clay was my favorite person in the world. Later my mom would take me to buy a 2Live Crew album and my dad would stand in line with me to get Mortal Kombat 2 for the Genesis because I wanted red blood; not grey sweat like the SNES offered.

I have always known these loudmouth politicians were full of crap because I turned out just fine... and I experienced the worst that entainment had to offer at a young age.

I don't do drugs or smoke. I've never been promiscuous (which isn't necessarily bad), I respect my wife and treat her well. And I'm a good father (if I do say so myself). The only run-in with the law was a speeding ticket as a teenager.

I saw many comments from people with the same childhood as mine and said they've all become perfectly functional and productive members of society. If a child is so strongly influenced that it makes him/her do bad things then there's obviously something wrong with that child and is not the product of the violence, sexuality or bad language in the world around them.

It's frustrating to see all these laws, rules, and regulations pushed on us because other parents are either too lazy or just outright ignore their child and their needs. That is what's sickening... not video games.

Default_picture
June 24, 2010

Thanks for the great read, and the smile.

Default_picture
June 24, 2010

Wow. I'm thinking a lot of commenters aren't parents. I have two kids, 8 and 10, who play video games, but I can tell you that in those first years we didn't play video games at all and in fact limited TV as much as possible. Kids that age need a different kind of stimulation as their brains develop.

You said your son seemed to calm down after you explained the difference between fantasy and reality. My guess is you explained it and assumed that was all he needed. Kids aren't capable of separating fantasy and reality typically until age 7, some even further out. That's a fact, not some anti-TV, anti-video game hyperbole. You cannot reason or argue logically with a child that age. Their brains are incapable of comprehending it.

I'm not saying you're a bad father. I'm saying it's not the best stimulation for a kid that age, by far. The best stimulation is face-to-face interaction with adults, reading together, playing with friends, going OUTSIDE. Being creative ... and not in the limited venue of a video game's world, particularly one as violent as GTA.

Headshot
June 25, 2010

I'm not going to do a whole lot of defending because it is what it is, but I'm surprised to see how many people assume my son sits in front of the TV 24 hours a day seven days a week. He's just like any other kid and enjoys playing outside pretending to be soldiers or playing hide-n-go-seek with all the other neighborhood kids. He also loves to read, and a matter of fact he placed high in his school for a program called Accelerated Reader.

I was going to do a companion piece to go along with this story because of all the negative feedback I've received. Mostly an answer to the people who said they wonder what kind of monster he would turn into in a couple of years. Well, surprise surprise! My son who is chronicled in this story is now almost 9 and besides the dead hooker I found under his bed last night he's a pretty cool kid. Ok I'm being sarcastic, but he is doing just fine.

I think I will follow up with the update to this story.

Default_picture
July 17, 2010

Excellent article. I surely wasn't expecting that, as someone said before "regains my faith in humanity" :)

Mitch_jul31
July 24, 2010

I have no shame in admitting to audibly saying "Bawwww!" when I read that your son refused to take someone else's car. It's strange to think that this is admirable behavior rather than the norm, but realistically, adults in the same situation would probably try to cause as much of a mess as possible. I mean, the first thing I'd do is take what I want, and then I'd follow it with doing what I want. It's weird how games have conditioned us to go for broke like that. Meanwhile, the purest of pure hearts have no interest in it because it's not even an idea that would come to them. I admire that.

Default_picture
September 11, 2010

I thought this was kinda adorable. A nice depiction of a innocent child. But afterwards I thought that you'd still have to monitor his gaming constantly. A little child is very open to influences and maybe doesn't completely see the difference between a game and real world. He doesn't steal a car because it's not right in real world. So what if someone told him that, in this game, it's okay to kill people and take their cars...? But this is just a scary thought that popped into my mind.

So this is not to say that I didn't find the article heart warming.

Headshot
September 11, 2010

It's great to see people are still reading this.

You make an excellent point Lol Paa. If he was told that it was possible to do wrong things in the game he would have probably tried it. But the point of this experiment was to see if he would prove those outspoken politcians right.

I'm very happy to say that their blanket statements on inappropriate material in games isn't true at all. In the end, it's the player and not the game.

Default_picture
October 12, 2010

Does anybody but me hate how adults keep saying "Violent videogames are corrupting our youth!!"? Is it just me, or are they just making up a load of BS to cover up the fact that they SUCK at parenting and buy their kids these games, then see them reenacting it.... Seriously parents, DON'T buy your kids M rated games if you're gonna complain about the results. For gamer parents: don't buy them AT ALL, then you won't have to chastice your child because they wanted to play the game you like so much. They don't think it's wrong, they barely know any better, but YOU do, so STOP putting the blame on game developers and take some responsibility for BUYING the game in the first damn place. JESUS.....

Default_picture
November 23, 2010

i think this, you know, is a good discussion and thanks matthew for being an excellent moderator.

video games, like any form of entertainment, live in sort of a gray area. that is, there really is no right or wrong way to approach them from a moral standpoint. it's gonna boil down to opinion. that being said, it isn't fair for anyone to judge anyone else for the way they handle them in their household.

here's what we do know: media in general (including video games) do not in any way cause harm by themselves. they will fit into whatever worldview the child is provided in their home.

Dsc049854
January 25, 2011

Great article, Matthew. Your son sounds like a good kid. :)

 

This reminds me of when I was playing GTA: SA at a friends house a number of years ago. My friend had decided to "borrow" another person's vehicle out in the middle of a street. At that point my friends mom asked "What are you doing?! Is he going to let you in?".

 

Video games--like anything else--are what you make them.

Shoe_headshot_-_square
May 10, 2011

Matthew, congrats! Your article made it to a magazine in China: http://bitmob.com/articles/my-four-year-old-son-plays-gtanow-in-china

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.