I agree with everything Danny said. When you read a choose-your-own adventure book, are you suddenly an author? Is that "your story"? The entire argument makes absolutely no sense."
If you're not an idiot for your honest opinion, then how can I be an idiot for mine? That's blatantly inconsistent. It's my opinion that anyone who demands that BioWare change the ending is an idiot. That's several steps beyond simply disliking it, which makes you a person with an opinion, not an idiot. As far as the games as art question, I don't think that's up for debate anymore. Every game is art to someone. Asteroids is art to some people. As is Gears of War. The fact is that it's subjective. But anyone who's demanding BioWare alter ME 3 to suit their personal taste has got to admit that it's NOT a work of art, otherwise they'd have to surrender to the whims of its auteurs (BioWare). Hence the question in the title."
The new game plus model is the perfect complement to this—you're encouraged to play again once you've reached the end, and if you play it slightly differently, do the bosses in a different order or backtrack a little before you move on, you'll always discover some new NPC interaction, a new item, a new covenant, or whatever.
Your Darkmoon Blade example—not everyone is meant to discover everything. It's as simple as that. Some people will wear that ring for the extra attunement slot and happen to go to that bonfire. That fraction of players will join that covenant and start enacting revenge on the players who are still just invading people. It's meant to be an online eco system, and when it works, it's really amazing."
I love the perks system, and so far I think I like the removal of attributes. One thing that's frustrated me is I find my destruction spells don't scale very well—they get really weak eventually, and tougher ones are sort of hard to come by. So at that point I begin to miss my intelligence stat.
Anyway, I'll get back to you again when I decide to follow up on this article. Thanks for reading and commenting!"











