As for your concerns about the Mass Effect series, I think what you described is exactly what action shooters need. I don't think controlling an injured, less functional Shepard would make the game any less fun as long as it was done right. Sure, it'll make the game harder, but lets be honest, if you're playing a Mass Effect game, you're looking for a challenge."
I get that nothing is ever guaranteed, but starting off on the wrong foot is never a good indication of things to come."
And I never claimed that the two mediums were innately incompatible. What's incompatible is the notion that someone can take poor game narrative and somehow make a great movie. Bad=good? Of course not.
Furthermore, in both the article and my reply to you I've conceded to the fact that there are games with impressive narrative quality out there and that I AM HOPING that those titles begin a trend of good movies because good=good, which, again, is what you're arguing.
Look, I agree with what you're saying, I truly do. But your opinion really isn't much different from mine."









