Demon’s Souls: Telling Story through Gameplay
Written by Rob Savillo   

Demon's Souls

The land is shrouded in blackness. Enemies are more resilient than ever, and new, more powerful foes lurk in dark corners. The stakes couldn’t be higher. After much patience and caution, I’ve finally set eyes on the prize -- a primeval demon.

I’ve been searching for colorless demon’s souls. There are only ten such souls available in each playthrough. These souls are unique in their designation as the only available upgrade for rare items. Up to five colorless souls can be applied to each item, which means that only two items per playthrough can be fully upgraded.

There are only a few ways to obtain these elusive souls, and my journey to obtain all ten in one playthrough has revealed another unique aspect of Demon’s Souls -- that the title uses gameplay to tell a specific story.

In the beginning of the game, I talked to the Crestfallen Warrior, a blue soul trapped in the Nexus. He’s trapped because he has lost his will to collect more souls. His predicament is meant to impart knowledge of one key component of survival in Boletaria -- I need to travel outside of the Nexus and collect souls, least my own soul slowly fade away.

As I journey onwards, the Crestfallen Warrior’s dialogue foreshadows my coming accomplishments -- he begins to comment on my regained body and on the demon’s souls I’ve acquired. He warns that my collecting of these souls will cause me to fall into the same trap as Allant.


The Crestfallen Warrior

The Crestfallen Warrior is, of course, referring to King Allant of Boletaria. In an effort to bring untold prosperity to his kingdom, Allant dabbled in the soul arts. His meddling awakened the Old One, an irrevocable poison strewn across the land with intentions to devour the souls of humankind.

In essence, Demon’s Souls sets up a reward system which specifically encourages the player to mold his character to reflect the plot developing behind the scenes. This became most evident to me through the hunt for colorless souls.

As I said, there are only a few ways to find these souls. The first one is easy and in plain sight, provided that you can bring the world’s tendency to either pure white or pure black. The next two are even easier than the first -- all the player needs to do is trade the right items for the souls.

The bulk of these souls are held by primeval demons; one is located in each of the five worlds connected to the Nexus. In order to bring the primeval demons out of hiding, I must descend each world’s tendency into pure blackness.

These account for eight of the ten -- the final two souls require the player to shift further towards blackness. They can be obtained through assassination quests, and the only way to be offered the quests is to shift your character’s tendency to pure black. How does one do so? By murdering characters in the game.

The game doesn't just encourage players to shift black through colorless souls, but also through world tendency events. Some pathways or characters are only ever available when a particular world is pure white or pure black. There are a limited number of ways to shift a world pure white, but there’s a limitless method to shift worlds black.

Worlds shift white when the player scourges the land of demons, specifically the major and chief demons of each realm. Once these demons are slain, there are few other noticeably effective ways to shift a world white. NPC black phantoms and primeval demons are the other major ways to shift a world white, but those methods are only available once a world is pure black and their effect can only be felt once.


Pure black world tendency

Shifting black, on the other hand, is really easy. All the player needs to do is perish while in body form. Any death -- suicide, death from the environment, death from an invading black phantom -- is enough to shift a world towards black. This method is effectively without limit, since a player always has the option to die.

To get the most out of Demon’s Souls in one run -- to get all the items, as many upgrades as possible, experience all tendency events -- players must work towards making Boletaria a harsher place to exist within. In doing so, the player has fallen into the same trap as Allant by furthering the goals of the Old One.

At the end of the game, the Old One opens an invitation to his realm. He has chosen you to become his next demon. Everything you have achieved in the game, from killing demons to murdering fellow characters, has brought you to this point. He’ll even offer the player one final chance to join him in his quest to consume the Earth in the deep, colorless fog.

The narrative is the story of your descent into darkness. You fall for the allure of power by killing demons to increase your soul level. By the end, you're murdering friendly humans who are unlucky enough to still be alive.

I should mention that players do have the option to lull the Old One back to sleep, and thus, save Boletaria from darkness. But such action will only immediately return the player to the Nexus for the next playthrough. At the end of the second run, players are again encouraged to join the Old One rather return him to eternal slumber -- the reward for joining is more than threefold the reward for setting the world straight.

Demon’s Souls does not impart this narrative through cut-scenes or dialogue choices. There is no morality or karma system. To completely experience the game, players are encouraged to become demons themselves. By taking advantage of specific game mechanics encouraged by the game itself, player actions further the story of Demon’s Souls.

Comments (6)

Rob, I bought Fallout 3 GOTY instead of this. Every time I read something about it - usually from you - it makes me think that perhaps I made the wrong choice. Everything about this game seems to be hardcore.

On a slightly different topic, what is the difference between a Succubus and Incubus?
Lance Darnell , November 19, 2009
Succubus = female.
Incubus = male.

Right?
James DeRosa , November 19, 2009
@James @Lance That's what my old D&D; Monster Manual taught me.
Jason Wilson , November 19, 2009
I give up -- I'm completely confused. What's happened in my comments section?
Rob Savillo , November 20, 2009
@Rob - Sorry Dude, I had demons on the brain last night. When a demon comes to rape me, I need to know if its a male or female. I'm choosey like that!

@James - I know a succubus is female, but then isn't a huccubus male?

@Jason - I have to pick up a D&D; manual!!! smilies/cheesy.gif
Lance Darnell , November 20, 2009
I have read a LOT of people complaining that Demon's Souls has no story. I find myself invariably unable to respond to these accusations: they just don't get it.

There is a TON of story in this game, you just have to experience it instead of read it. My personal favorite vignette is "the Old Monk's revenge and the profaning of the church"
Tommy Ingallinera , November 20, 2009

Write comment

You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

 


On Bitmob
Home
Mobfeed
Podcasts
Copyright Bitmob Media 2009

SITE DESIGN BY Karen Chu