Five Cities Not Named New York to Set Your Game In

Default_picture
Friday, June 19, 2009

Editor's Note: The recently-announced Max Payne 3 takes place in São Paulo, Brazil, so maybe not every game these days is set in New York. Still, Suriel makes some good points. Though I'm not yet sold on Omaha! -Demian



I've never been to New York City, but from all of the photos, videos, games, movies, coffee mugs, etc., I think I have a pretty good idea of what it looks like.

It's a metropolis, filled with lots of great cultures and ideas. And with so many producers of media hailing from there or having lived there and grown to love its expansive urban jungle environment, it's understandable that many of our cultural influences originate from there. Both Batman and Superman live in fictionalized versions of New York City, and Spider-Man is actually from there. It's the most prolific city in the world as far as media goes, and the image of the Statue of Liberty watching over the sprawling landscape of concrete and metal was one of the most iconic images of America in my head before I moved here at the age of four (ironically, I arrived in Anaheim, CA, which is known for its own iconic, castle-based architecture).

That said, I think it's about time we take a break from NYC.

When an open-world game doesn't take place somewhere made up, it usually takes place in New York. Prototype takes place there, and Infamous takes place somewhere that's pretty much a fictional version of it, as does Grand Theft Auto 4. And I see why; NYC offers not only one of the biggest, most fleshed-out cities to wreak havoc upon, but it's also one that many people are familiar with. However, I think it's safe to say that New York's been done. If you're a developer looking for somewhere else to set your fantastic new sandbox game in, here are some wonderful new places to consider. Also, would you like to buy a timeshare?

Tokyo: Pretty much your runner up as far as familiar locations go. Most people think they know what Tokyo's like, and really, it's not too much different from that, but having all of its districts, lights, Japanese culture, and all those weird walkways would make for a pretty cool place to break some shit. Japan has plenty of other exciting, scenic places to explore outside of Tokyo, as well. Not only that, but Tokyo inhabitants should be pretty used to the idea of having their city destroyed. Plus, there's totally a giant robot there now. (More after the jump.)

 

Hong Kong: You might not think that Hong Kong is too different from Tokyo, but you'd be wrong. It's an amazing mix of Eastern and Western culture, and it's very much a business district, but all that does is make it more tempting to destroy. Not only is it the world's most verticle city, it also has an extensive coastline, ideal for fast-paced cigarette boat chases (or slow-paced junk boat chases). Plus, it's apparently where lots of seedy business deals go down, so if you're going to destroy a place, why not stop rotten business at the same time?

Berlin: Now, for this suggestion, think post-WWII Berlin. Say your character has powers like those in Infamous or Prototype; a Berlin-based game could involve you fighting a communist regime by hopping back and forth between the East and West, completing spy missions to help try to feed and free the citizens of the East. Or forget the super powers idea and imagine an open-world stealth game. Maybe you could help Reagan make his speech to tear down that wall, using the Motion Plus to write it word for word, of course.

Mumbai: Now for something a little less Western, but no less fun to roam around in. Mumbai has fantastic architecture and numerous, culturally-significant landmarks, as well as densely populated slums. There's also a chance here to have us Westerners learn a thing or two about another culture -- and if the protagonist were Indian rather than American, maybe we could avoid some of the ethnocentrism that Eastern cultures so pointedly remind us of.

Omaha, Nebraska: I have to make an argument for my current residence! Really, though, I think open-world games could use a setting that's a little less urban. For those of you who are worried about not being able to run-climb up buildings, we do have a business district here, and the buildings are made from metal and glass, just like yours. GTA San Andreas had a pretty big non-urban area, and even though people harped on it for not having anything to do there there, I think the combination of urban and rural areas still has plenty of potential. For example, if you wanted to kill a certain target without destroying half a city, why not do it where no one will see you?

Again, I don't hate New York/New Yorkers or anything, but I think that so far they've been getting a pretty big piece of the pie (like they usually do). So if you're looking for some scenic, interesting areas to set your triple-A title in, why not give these a shot? Or maybe you have a suggestion of your own?

 
Problem? Report this post
SURIEL VAZQUEZ'S SPONSOR
Comments (14)
Default_picture
June 19, 2009
Haha. its funny, cus i live in nyc, so its always fun to see a game set in my town, or modeled very similarly. tho sometimes its really frustrating to me when a game is "modeled" after Nyc, but when i run around in it, I end up feeling like its accurate, but ends up feeling flat and uninspired (prototype, and spiderman 2 come to mind), and as a result i end up feeling more disappointed with the locale than a non NYC native would feel.
Demian_-_bitmobbio
June 19, 2009
If you can find a nice image for each of these cities that you can legally use (creative commons license or something), I'll put this on the front page.
Default_picture
June 19, 2009
Done! Pretty sure I picked free images.
Pshades-s
June 19, 2009
Tokyo gets enough coverage as it is. Give us more games set in Osaka (much more manageable than the massive capital of Japan) or maybe Kyoto (which has historical sights and is a nice grid of a town). As far as the US goes, why not more games set in San Francisco? That should butter up all the game journalists who live there and it's a beautiful city to boot.
Default_picture
June 20, 2009
I say why not in any of the Scandinavian countries? Been keen on Sweden myself.
Profile_pic4
June 20, 2009
I, too, am a big fan of San Francisco as a choice, having lived there myself for 4 years. In fact, living an additional 10 years in Santa Clara (southern part of the Bay Area for those not familiar) makes me submit that Burnout in particular would benefit from a Bay Area treatment as a whole. Skyline Boulevard, Hwy 1, Infinity Loop, Chinatown, the Golden Gate and bridges (as well as 100's of add'l locations) would all offer fantastic Burnout translation in a virtual space.
Default_picture
June 20, 2009
I would love to play a game set in Hong Kong. Its settings are pretty diverse. Tokyo is awesome too as shown in Yakuza. Hopefully the next Assassin's Creed will take place in ancient Asia.
Default_picture
June 20, 2009
I'd say Canada, but we're essentionally a colder version of the United States. Next-gen cold air, anyone?
Default_picture
June 20, 2009
I know you have to rep your zip code, but as charming as Omaha is, it's far to small and boring to set most video games. That said, there are plenty of games that have rural/suburban settings (like Bully) that would probably benefit from taking place in a real life town like Omaha or Fresno, CA. Also, setting a video game in Mumbai, especially one with violence is probably a terrible idea thanks to the recent terrorists attacks there. If you want that a similar location that's rich with history and contrasts the bleak shanty towns with the rich and modern developments, I suggest Mexico City. Tokyo is basically the NYC of Japan and kind of boring at this point. What would be great is some other famous but rarely used cities like Rome, Istanbul, Cairo, Sidney, Lima, Cape Town, etc. Basically, I would kill for more games that don't take place in either the US, Japan, or Europe during WW2.
Default_picture
June 20, 2009
I thought it was hilarious that the spaceship (or whatever) in MDK2 landed in Edmonton, AB. ;D Too bad nothing in the game actually takes place in Edmonton, but hey, at least we got [i]something[/i].
Default_picture
June 21, 2009
I think Omaha would be a great place. Children of the corn style.
Default_picture
June 21, 2009
How about the 2nd city, Chicago? It has some pretty unique landmarks that would be interesting in a game like Infamous IMO.
Default_picture
June 21, 2009
I'm thinking maybe something more exotic like Madrid
Default_picture
June 22, 2009
Why not Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia? Twin Towers & Catherine Zeta-Jones, anyone?

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.