How my friend proved that Super Mario World is the best SNES game

Default_picture
Wednesday, August 24, 2011
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Rob Savillo

Is relative unfamiliarity with a passion indicative of an ability to pick out the best that hobby has to offer? Louis argues just that as he realized the wisdom of a friend while he hunted for her Super Nintendo birthday gift.

A friend of mine turned 20 in July, and while I was driving around the state of Wisconsin (for just under 400 miles) looking for a working copy of Yoshi's Island and Super Mario Kart for her birthday, I realized something: On August 23 (or some date roughly around then according to conflicting sources on Wikipedia), the Super Nintendo turns 20 years old, too. Quite the sobering thought if you've been a gamer for a while.

As always, countless video-game reporters and fans will post their thoughts about what the best games on Nintendo's sophomore console are and what the system means to them.

I have my own thoughts on what titles are the best on the gray-and-purple box, but then I realized something else: My friend (probably) knows what the best two games are for the system, and she could care less.

I say probably because she didn't even talk to me about this or even know the Super Nintendo was just a month younger than her. The way I know the two games she obsesses over are the two best ones for the system -- and ones that everyone should play -- are two-fold: She obsessively plays them but isn't a hardcore gamer, and she's better than (probably) most people on this site at them.

 

I'm using probably a lot, but hear me out.

She's in love with Super Mario World and Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island -- Yoshi's Island being a recent obsession but an obsession nonetheless. It speaks volumes that she talks about getting Yoshi in a sleeve tattoo to add to her heavily inked body after playing both.

But I digress.

So then, how can a casual gamer who excels at Super Nintendo side-scrollers but turns up her nose at people who dare play some Castlevania: Lords of Shadow instead of Donkey Kong Country Returns possibly convince a die-hard gamer like me that those two titles should be experienced? How is it that my expertise on the matter (Nintendo Power posters cover every inch of my bedroom wall) could possibly lead me astray? Surely, we hardest of the hardcore -- I'm talking Geodude hard -- know best.

Easy. It's the fact that she doesn't care, yet like every Angry Birds lover, she has both games as a part of her life -- a life that mainly consists of your typical partying, college-level-soccer goal keeping, and never knowing what a Bitmob is...or even wanting to know.

Video-game journalists and die-hard players like me should -- or at least I think we should -- be the most educated or experienced people to pick out what the best Super Nintendo game is.

But the fact that this casual gamer, who probably plays her 20-year-old system more than anything else and knows the Soda Pop Islands like the back of her goalie-glove-wearing hand, leaves me with only one answer: She's right, and she should be. Even if she doesn't know it or care, that's an amazing feat. How often do you find someone who isn't necessarily into a hobby or sport latch onto a piece of it with such vigor? Not often.

I couldn't even tell you why she likes it other than that she has fun playing it. Sometimes that's enough. For others, they'd have to explain the how and why as if it were a high-school dating scene: “Well, we both like each other because we like to play soccer.”

Instead of these juvenile reasons, she displays something else: an unexplainable feeling -- perhaps something akin to what lovers feel when they've found that something special that cannot be explained away so easily -- as to why she loves running around with a mustached plumber and, more importantly, a green dinosaur.

She blasted through most of Yoshi's Island in two days, and she's been a master of Super Mario World for countless years -- I shudder when we play co-op because of the insults and fun she has at my dying Luigi's expense.

Playing with her as a die-hard gamer will make you question your gaming skills, but one thing is for sure: If she's this absorbed in the world of Super Mario -- or Super Mario World and Yoshi's Island, rather -- then you should be celebrating the system's birthday with these two gems.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (6)
Default_picture
August 24, 2011

I think that "could NOT care less" is what you meant to say at the end of the 3rd paragraph.  Good article overall though.  I think that Super Mario World is one of the best games of all time.

Default_picture
August 24, 2011

The term "could care less" haunted my brain the entire time I was reading the rest of the article.

Default_picture
August 24, 2011

I guess that your casual gamer friend is into Super Mario World and Yoshi's Island is cool, but I'm not sure why you think that's supposed to have any wider implications for the rest of us. You have to consider that tastes are incredibly subjective, and that there is the very real possibility that whether they consider themselves hardcore or not, certain gamers might not consider those two games their cup of tea even if they can appreciate that they're well made. I doubt that your friend's interest in them is going to change their mind about them if they didn't already like them.

This isn't a bad article by any stretch, but I just don't get how or why you came to the conclusion that you did. We like what we like, y'know?  

Redeye
August 24, 2011

Well interpritation of this article is easily as subjective as one's taste in games, and I hardly think complaining about a common and relatively unimportant grammar snafu really helps the discussion either.

I personally like Yoshi's island the best out of any SNES game because of one reason: Accessibility. The game gives you a recharging timer count down to retrieve baby mario when you get hit instead of a life bar or a 1 or 2 hit death scheme. That allowed me to get into it and get better at it then pretty much any other SNES game while still having plenty of collectibles that turned 100 percenting each mission into a fun challenge.

It was just fun and forgiving enough for me to keep playing and get good at it while other games like zelda and castlevania were pissing me off enough for me to turn them off.

Default_picture
August 24, 2011

I think it's just a good way of showing the power that is Super Mario. Everyone, casual or hardcore, loves the series. These two games would make my top two in a best Super Nintendo game list, and the fact that most casual gamers I know love them is pretty cool. Maybe it does just boil down to her liking old-school sidescrollers, but maybe it's that Nintendo magic that both Super Mario World games have!

And Yoshi's Island is for sure my number one. That game is something else!

Default_picture
August 24, 2011

And I did kind of post this to see what kind of debate I could stir up! So your comments are welcome!

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.