Today’s guitar-shredding Pokémon is losing its charm

Default_picture
Tuesday, September 25, 2012
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Eduardo Moutinho

Pokémon is like a multi-generational Saturday-morning cartoon. Each year, it adds another wacky layer until it eventually becomes something quite different.

Pokémon

Pokémon Black Version 2 and Pokémon White Version 2 are just around the corner. Maybe I don't keep an eye on the right media outlets anymore, but somehow, I've missed out on the hype train for these releases. I thought now might be a good time to get informed, so I headed over to the official Pokémon site to get the company line.

I came away with this.

 

Pokémon has really undergone a scale shift since I was a kid. I suspect that in order to keep the attention of today's youth against competitors offering an “everything is deadly serious” mood, Nintendo had to up the ante. Let's break down what you just experienced:

  • Guitar-shredding “extreme” versions of tunes from the video game soundtrack
  • Wildly apocalyptic public collateral damage that fazes nobody (including flash freezing an entire city block)
  • Every bad guy engaging in nonsensical anime villain monologues
  • More fantastical Tokyo pop fashion than you can shake a stick at
  • An overabundance of ninjas
  • "I'm about to unleash my rage" guy at the 4:10 mark that came just shy of making me do a spit take.

Having absorbed this wildly outlandish spectacle, I'm struggling to extract meaning from it all. Has the target age demographic for Pokémon changed, or is it the same group but requiring higher standards to induce awe?

Pokémon 2Back when I was a kid (he said, suddenly feeling more old and crotchety than he ever thought possible), the stories of Pokémon games centered on becoming something like a cross between a boy scout and a child athlete. Your character traipsed through the wilderness dueling bug catchers, hikers, and swimmers (granted, with a suspicious acceptance for everyday sports gambling) to train for the big tournament with the Elite Four, after which you (presumably) went out for ice cream and came home to a warm bed. At the game world's most sinister point, you climbed a tower that acknowledged that these little critters would die someday, or you took on a whimsical parody of organized crime in Team Rocket.

Now it seems like the hero can't even be asked to walk out the door for anything short of laying waste to the countryside, dueling against famous idol singers, or “unleashing” his “rage.”

Maybe this is just the nature of intellectual properties targeted toward children. Every day, new kids are aging into the Pokémon target demographic (whatever age that might be). They're coming in with more and more jaded criteria for what is and isn't mind blowing. Publisher Nintendo and developer Game Freak are just doing what they have to in order to keep up in a rapidly and constantly evolving (pun intended) entertainment market.

None of this is going to stop me from buying the games this October, mind you. Having grown up watching anime, I still have a soft spot for the ridiculous. And the most recent games in the main series were a joy to play, demonstrating some of the finest iterative polish of any franchise in the industry. But I'll make those purchases with a self-aware chuckle and the understanding that while I'm still playing Pokémon, it's no longer that light-hearted adventure that first delighted me.


Robert Wiesehan is challenging himself to write five books and lose 92 pounds before he turns 30. He shares ideas and motivation twice each week on his video blog.

 
Problem? Report this post
ROBERT WIESEHAN'S SPONSOR
Comments (5)
Dscn0568_-_copy
September 24, 2012

I'm not a huge Poke fan, but I enjoyed it. To me the video is kind of like playing with Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles or Power Rangers toys. In your mind they were doing crazy things that would never happen in the show with its limited budget and censorship standards (not blood or cursing, but even the small things that censors have a beef with). So it is cool to see the dramatic speeches and over-the-top moments like the dog biting the snake in the neck because in the games you mainly have the top-down perspective and a bunch of digitized effects. It's showing what you want to feel in the game.

Default_picture
September 25, 2012

Thanks for the comment, Chris. I absolutely did (and still do) exactly what you described as far as imagining new storylines and effects. (I'll contain the urge to share my ill-conceived Pokemon fanfic ideas...)

While there's nothing wrong with Pokemon taking on this tone, it's definitely something that's not happening on accident. It's not as innocent of a property as it once was. This could just speak to focus testing determining that parental definitions of what's acceptable content have gotten more permissive since the original 151 little guys came to the US around 14 years ago. So it goes.

Default_picture
September 25, 2012

 

I understand your misgivings with the tonal shift, though is this not more of an issue with the connected anime rather than the games themselves? As you said; the Pokemon titles are a great example of positive iteration within games and to that end I don’t recall them deviating from the basic narrative structure set out within red and blue. From the looks of the video in question, however, the anime appears to have changed drastically. When I was young it was all lighthearted goofiness and now it seems to have taken a decidedly more dramatic tone. I haven’t watched the TV show for well over a decade but I play the games every other iteration, so it seems the show has deviated from the tone of the games quite significantly. I do understand this though; a show running at over seven hundred episodes has to develop much more radically than a series of games released every couple of years. I stopped watching the series because it’s inherent animeness got too much for me, and it stopped resembling my interpretation of the games. I’d leave the series and its trapping to the children of the world and enjoy the games for what they are; a deceptively deep rpg experience wrapped up in the cotton wool of a children’s game.

Dscn0568_-_copy
September 25, 2012

Honestly from what I've seen the anime has mostly been the same as it's always been. With Black and White they rebooted things somewhat by replacing Brock for good, turning Ash into an idiot again, and making Team Rocket competent, but even then there wasn't any real tonal shift. Not even electric guitars. Actually, this clip is interesting because of how different it is from the show as well. It's a Michael Bay version of it.

Default_picture
September 29, 2012

 

Aah, then I renounce my opinions due to lack of any actual knowledge. As with most populist anime there is usually too much of it for me to jump in, with pokemon I left in about 2000 and now I see there is over 600 episodes; impenetrable for me now. I was going from my memories and a little viewing therafter, apoligies.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.