I Live in Fallout 3

Dcswirlonly_bigger
Wednesday, December 02, 2009

Editor's note: As a Washington D.C. resident, Daniel looks at the fidelity of Fallout 3's game world. All that subtlety was lost on me -- I've never been there! -Demian


When I first heard of Fallout 3, I was interested in it primarily because it's set in the very place on Earth where I live. That's a very rare thing for us non-New York City or California residents -- as famous as Washington D.C. is, being the capital of a world superpower and all, it’s actually not explored much in fiction beyond the Pentagon and the White House. People know what the monuments look like, but very little about what the city itself actually feels like.

Fallout 3 developer Bethesda takes their name from their home base of Bethesda, Maryland, which is right by D.C. This is really a local developer setting a game in their own backyard, sort of like what Sega is doing with the Yakuza series.

So how accurately does Fallout 3 portray the D.C. metro area? In my opinion, much more accurately than expected considering it’s a post-apocalyptic version of an alternate-world D.C., with “World of Tomorrow” overtones. For example, I know someone who, when tasked with finding the Declaration of Independence, looked up its real location on Google Maps and used that to find it in the game.

 

The most accurate elements of D.C. in Fallout 3 are obviously the district’s most famous features -- the monuments of the inner Mall. As you may have seen, they’ve got The White House and Washington Monument and all, and the Jefferson plays a major role in the story as well.

To someone who has actually been to those monuments, Fallout 3’s depiction is actually a little more striking than expected, because the layout of inner D.C. is just about perfect. I remember people twittering during the Obama inauguration that every time they looked at the scene they wondered who was on super mutant duty. If you want to know what it’s like to stand in front of the Lincoln Memorial and see the Washington Monument with the Capitol building behind it in the distance, playing Fallout 3 really won’t put you far off.

Fallout 3 also gets some minor details right that I found pleasantly surprising -- things that people not living in D.C. wouldn’t recognize.

Most strikingly, the metros are all pretty much dead-on. The architectural design and layouts are about 85% congruent between the game and real life. The only major differences come from Fallout 3’s atomic-age art style. Even the names and locations of most of the metros in the game are real.

The shape of the Potomac River is also spot-on, as are a lot of the towns and other areas in D.C. Where I live, Fairfax, is represented by the Fairfax ruins. There’s nothing of particular interest there, but it was still cool visiting the location I’m actually playing the game from.

Even more subtle stuff like the general feel of the land is accurate. I’ve seen people on message boards complaining about hills and varying elevations in Fallout 3, and asking if the D.C. area really is this hilly. Guess what, it is.

This may sound like a bad joke, but downtown D.C. in real life is probably more violent than it is in Fallout 3 in terms of the number of crimes and deaths.

On a macro level, Fallout 3 does depict a generally inaccurate view of the D.C. area in terms of geographical distance and size -- understandably, the game world is significantly scaled down.

However, I think Bethesda did miss some opportunities. D.C. includes a handful of military bases, but none of them are represented in Fallout 3 in name or location, despite the game's abundance of forts.

Fallout 3's Fort Independence lies right outside of the Fairfax ruins. The real Fairfax County contains Fort Belvoir, but the many other bases, barracks, and military labs in the area didn't seem to make the cut.

My biggest disappointment with Fallout 3’s depiction of D.C. is the Pentagon (known as the Citadel in-game). I've visited the inside of the Pentagon more than once -- the guys at Bethesda probably weren’t so lucky, but I’ve still got to be picky due to the missed potential of the place.

The Pentagon is actually far more than a massive military office building shaped like a pentagon. It’s kind of its own society, complete with a mall and food court. It's a compound that could've translated into a whole town in Fallout 3, not unlike Rivet City. The Pentagon was the one D.C. monument I had to visit twice in order to actually recognize in Fallout 3.

I definitely wouldn’t say you should use Fallout 3 as a virtual road map for D.C., but if you visit after playing the game you might be surprised at what you recognize. Still, it’s pretty fascinating to play a game set in the area in which you (and the developers themselves) live. You New Yorkers and Californians know what I'm talking about.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (18)
Default_picture
December 01, 2009
I always enjoy things like this. I remember skating Embarcadero in the San Francisco level in Tony Hawk 4 and my dad telling me he did some tile work around there. One thing you have to take into account is that the D.C. in Fallout 3 was obliterated in a nuclear blast sometime in the 40's or 50's, if I'm not mistaken. So some things absent from the game may have not been built in that timeline. Great article, but I would've like to see more comparison pictures!
There184
December 01, 2009
It wasn't bombed in the '50s; it was bombed sometime near the start of this century. The Fallout universe diverges from the real one in the '40s, staying culturally similar - jazz, McCarthyism, etc. - while getting more technologically advanced. [/end nerdy pedanticism] I got a kick from seeing my house in 3D on Google Earth, so I can imagine how much fun it'd be to shoot some raiders outside it.
Nick_with_grill
December 01, 2009
I like the "I live here," picture. That's great man. Good job comparing multiple landmarks. I think the authenticity of a place can really enhance the game play, especially for someone familiar with the area. Do the bathrooms in the metros look that bad in real life?
Brett_new_profile
December 02, 2009
When I picked up Grand Theft Auto 4, the first thing I did was tool around my old neighborhoods of Sunnyside, Queens, and Williamsburg. Rockstar actually included the Sunnyside metal arch that greets you coming off the 7 line! Even though the geography was off (NYC is condensed like in Fallout), nailing those little details really made the city come alive for me. Daniel, what'd you think of Modern Warfare 2's interpretation of D.C.?
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
[quote]Do the bathrooms in the metros look that bad in real life? [/quote] As long as I don't see anyone drinking from the toilets, I can excuse the mess.
Twitpic
December 02, 2009
Very cool! I really had no idea, since I've never been to D.C. Great article!
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
"That's a very rare thing for us non-New York City or California residents -- as famous as Washington D.C. is, being the capital of a world superpower and all" AMERICA IS NOT THE DAMN WORLD SUPER POWER!
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
Anyone know how accurately The Pitt depicts Pittsburgh? I live in the Pittsburgh area, and I plan to eventually play this.
Demian_-_bitmobbio
December 02, 2009
'a guest' -- it says *A* world superpower. Not *THE* world superpower. Good luck trying to argue against that.
Normal_f3c8726ca7d523c031f09eb7d4e54430
December 02, 2009
@Michael DC was bombed in 2077 in the Fallout universe, not the 40s or 50s. The city has a 40s and 50s vibe because at that time technology was advancing so fast that they basically got stuck in that time period
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
@Nick Giunta [quote]Do the bathrooms in the metros look that bad in real life? [/quote] If real-life Metro stations have bathrooms, they're not public. I hope, for the station managers' sake, they're cleaner than those in the game.
Face-4
December 02, 2009
@Andrew Reda: Geographically, not so well. You DO enter the area via a tunnel and a bridge, but there aren't recognizable landmarks or neighborhoods. It's split into Downtown and Uptown - Downtown is claustrophobic and draws aesthetically from steel mill imagery; Uptown is an Ewok village with buildings instead of trees. I played it right after it was released and don't remember much else about it. Not exactly a ringing endorsement...
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
I would like to see more games set in real-world locations. Haven't played it yet, but I hear Assassin's Creed 2 does a pretty accurate job with Florence, Italy. I live in California, yet I'm still eight hours from L.A., so I don't spend any time there. Maybe some games set in San Francisco or even Sacramento would be cool for us NorCals to play.
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
I live here too. I could walk to Dukovs. Yeah, there are no bathrooms in metro stations. Apparently, Jet wasn't as big of a deal in the FO universe.
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
Daniel, nice article. I've thought about picking up Fallout 3 in part because I used to live in D.C. proper and grew up in the nearby Virginia suburbs. I don't suppose the Tastee Diner makes an appearance? It would be nice to see more games set in the DC metro area. I got a kick out of playing the Northern Virginia sections of Modern Warfare 2, although it would've been nicer if Infinity Ward created a more faithful representation of the area instead of making them look like any old American suburban neighborhood. The mention of I-95 at the beginning of that mission gave me goosebumps and the PG County reference was a nice touch too. Too bad there wasn't a shout out to specific D.C. neighborhoods like Adams Morgan, Mt. Pleasant, or Dupont Circle. It'll be interesting to see how D.C. is portrayed in the next Splinter Cell game. I'm guessing Sam Fisher will be relegated to the mall area like an 8th grader on a school fieldtrip, but who knows maybe we'll see an interrogation scene in the bathroom of Ben's Chili Bowl!
Default_picture
December 02, 2009
So Daniel, post nuclear D.C. at night or present day D.C. at night? I have to ask. At least there are probably random encounter tables for what you will run into in Fallout 3's D.C. In reality it is probably much more random and frightening.
Default_picture
June 10, 2011

Great article! But can someone tell me what Bigtown's REAL name is, it's a pain to google search DC maps, and compare it to the map IG. 

Default_picture
September 21, 2012
Big Town hehe that's CIA headquarters.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.