Separator

Romance Is Something Else

Me
Friday, November 26, 2010

  

When I was a kid, I remember my parents bringing home a brand new, VHS, 50th Anniversary edition of Casablanca.  They went on and on about how great it was, even going so far as to call it the ~ gasp ~ best movie ever. When they would try to get me to watch it, however, I wouldn't even give it a chance, and I imagine most kids were probably like me.  Casablanca simply is not a kids movie.  

Well, now I'm older, I've seen Casablanca many times, and I've come to understand what good ol' Mom and Dad were talking about.  It has become one of my favorite movies, and, on some days at least, I do place it at the top of the 'Best Movies of All Time' list.  But what is it about Casablanca that doesn't interest a kid yet does interest an adult?  Well kids, get ready to put your hands over your eyes and say eww!  The secret ingredient is romance.  

I remember reading an article awhile back by James DeRosa called "Violence, Victory, and the Difficulties of Making a Cheerful Game."   In it, he argues that there needs to be a fundamental change in the purpose of video games, from achieving victory to... something else.  What that something else is is unclear.  http://www.bitmob.com/articles/video-games-need-to-grow-down

This is a very interesting line of thought.  I'm not sure, however, that 'victory' is necessarily the problem, as sometimes getting the girl can be a victory.  And I, nor do I think DeRosa, is arguing for getting rid of violent games.  What I am saying is that romance is virtually nonexistent in video games, and that it may be the alternative to violence and children's games many of us are looking for.  

Frequent mention has been made lately by older gamers, gamers who grew up with Mario and Sonic, that the new side-scrolling versions of these classic games, while well-done, do not hold their interest like they expected them to.  Indeed, even the old classics like Super Mario World and Sonic The Hedgehog have lost some of their appeal.  This should be of little surprise, as our needs as adults are not the same as the needs of children.  (I do want to note, too, how strange I think it is that children, teenagers, and adults are basically buying and playing the same games.) 

But I think it is possible that an inevitable progression is going on in the world of video games right now.  Those of us who spent our childhoods rescuing a princess in what amounts to the video game equivalent of a Disney movie have grown up.  We can appreciate the creativity of games like Mario, but it really is kids stuff.  Where are the games that only adults want to play?  Where is the video game equivalent of Casablanca?    

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (8)
Assassin_shot_edited_small_cropped
November 27, 2010

Yeah, I'd love to see some more games that deal with "mature" themes such as romance, love, and betrayal. The odd game does pop up, but seldom with any real depth.

You could argue that these themes don't appear much because they are difficult to do right in a video game, but at this point I'd call that a cop-out. Final Fantasy 6 did it well, given the technological constraints, [i]sixteen[/i] years ago, with suicide, love, betrayal, greed, and hate all included. Today, there's no reason we can't match -- if not better -- the quality and depth of FF6's story (hopefully with a better translation, if it is not written in English).

Me
November 27, 2010

I'm a huge fan of Final Fantasy 6!  It's amazing how well that game was made.

Dscn0568_-_copy
November 27, 2010

Romance is tough to put into a game since (not to be poetic) expressing love involves many more nuances than expressing violence. The industry probably has to take baby steps with this; things like the black-and-white morality shown in many games have to be challenged first before we can move on to love.

Robsavillo
November 30, 2010

Have you tried Heavy Rain? I think it addresses romance in an entirely adult fashion.

Me
November 30, 2010

@Rob:  No, I haven't.  I'll have to check it out... I always wonder when I write an article like this if there's some game out there I missed that actually addresses what I'm talking about.   

Default_picture
November 30, 2010

"Where is the video game equivalent of Casablanca?"

May I suggest looking into the Visual Novel genre? And yes, by Visual Novels I do mean "Japanese anime porn games", which, for some strange reason, usually contain actual stories instead of simply being a series of excuses for showing people having sex with each other. I'd suggest "Kana: Little Sister" as the best example of the genre that I'm aware of.

On a non-X rated note, there's Persona 3 and Persona 4, which don't quite manage to take us as far as adulthood, but do manage to get beyond childhood enough to enter high school.

Robsavillo
November 30, 2010

Ryan, I think you still have a point in general. Heavy Rain is not exactly a typical video-game experience.

Default_picture
December 01, 2010

You can also try Indigo Prophecy, it's also made by Quantic Dream. It's not filled with Romance, but arguably is a game that appeals much more to adults than children. Most children will turn away from it. It's the closest thing to a video game equivalent of "Children of Men" (the movie) that I've played yet. It's not close enough for my tastes, but it's a wonderful game on its' own right. The only complaint that I have is that the uncensored version is not easily available in the U.S.. Even the digital Steam copy is censored.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.