The Ultimate JRPG Buyer's Guide for RPG Haters

Default_picture
Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Editor's note: Although I wouldn't classify myself as a JRPG hater, I do find most of them stale and boring. So Brian's buyer's guide comes as a pleasant surprise: It's filled with wildly diverse games that I now want to play. I think I'll start with Super Mario RPG... -Brett


I don't use the word "hater" lightly, but let's face it: There are a lot of Japanese role-playing game haters out there. If you find yourself flaming message boards whenever a JRPG is mentioned, there's a good chance that you're a part of this camp.

You could also be diagnosed as a JRPG hater if any of the following is true: you cringe whenever you see an effeminate male character, you break your controller by the time you enter your second turn-based battle, or you scream obscenities immediately after discovering that your characters are out to save the world.

Fortunately for you, I'm not going to attempt to cure your hatred for JRPGs. Instead, I'd like to get you to temporarily set aside your hatred by discussing a number of games that may appeal to gamers aren't attracted to Cloud Strife's spiky hair. The JRPG genre is actually quite robust if you look closely. During this four-part series, I'll cover a range of Japanese role-playing games, action-RPGs, strategy-RPGs, and more. I guarantee you'll find something you'll like.

So if you're ready to read about a trio of unconventional role-playing games, climb aboard my airship, and let's go for a ride!

 

Super Mario RPG: Give Me Action, Give Me Humor, Give Me Maarrio!

JRPGs notoriously feature battles that are either monotonous, strategic, or a combination of both. Regardless of their orientation, they rarely have much action, which is one of the reasons the genre doesn't appeal to impatient gamers. Fortunately, Square and Nintendo brutally butt-stomped those hoary JRPG conventions with Super Mario RPG for the Super Nintendo.

Super Mario RPG quickly became a beloved classic -- even among those who weren't RPG fans -- thanks to battles that required timed button presses instead of bland menus. For example, say you attacked with Mario. You'd initiate a first strike simply by tapping 'A' in the menu -- but then you could follow up with another roundhouse blow by pressing the A button right after his first attack connected. Each character had a variety of these timed attacks, all performed in unique ways, and this made Super Mario RPG a hit among RPG and action game fans alike.

Another way in which Super Mario RPG permanently altered the role-playing genre was through its use of humor. Up until its release, the plots of most RPGs weighed heavy with serious themes, but Super Mario RPG changed the game by making players laugh during nearly every scene. What caused players to LOL? Little details, like mute Mario's hilarious animations during such awkward moments as kissing the king of the Koopas. Of course, the pitch-perfect dialogue helped, too -- especially lines involving Toad leaving his bazooka at home, which caused me to regain respect for the Mario series' infamous eunuch.

How to play it: Purchase it for $8 on the Wii's Virtual Console.

Want more action and humor? Check out: Mario and Luigi series and Paper Mario series.


Mother 3: Tragedy, Quirky Humor, and Societal Transformation

Fans of the legendary Mother series still mourn the day Nintendo announced that Mother 3 would never escape the island nation of Japan. Everyone else of course didn't care, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't find a way to play the superb fan-translated version of Mother 3.

What makes this follow-up to Earthbound special is the fact that it retained the Mother series' quirky humor while providing a thought-provoking take on capitalism and creating one of gaming's most tragic moments at the same time. For every goofy booty-shaking dance and Pork Army soldier you'll encounter during the game's eight chapters, you'll find an interesting societal transformation that may even cause staunch supporters of capitalism to question our economic system.

How to play it: Purchase the original on eBay and play the English version on an emulator.

Don't mind turn-based battles and grinding? Then try: Earthbound (SNES) and Mother (NES).


Terranigma: Hate Predictable Story Lines? Try This Mysterious Title

Role-playing game haters often complain that JRPG stories are too predictable. Those people might want want to check out an RPG with a more opaque plot, such as Terranigma (a game I recently reviewed). Unfortunately, the only way to play this action-RPG is through an emulator (unless you have a grand to spend on a European SNES cartridge), but it's worth experiencing if you like your games full of action and mystery.

Terranigma's combat, puzzles, and tools will remind you of Zelda, but its story line of dualistic themes and world revival keep it from feeling like a Hyrulian clone. Not many games allow you to play God and determine the future of the world while discovering its past, so that alone makes Terranigma worth experiencing.

How to play it: Play the European English translation on an emulator.

Can't pronounce the title? Then try these single-player action-RPGs: ActRaiser, Soul Blazer, Illusion of Gaia, Final Fantasy Adventure, and Secret of Evermore.


With plenty of action, diatribes on capitalism, and mysteries to solve, you have enough to keep you busy for awhile. But stay tuned for a trio of equally unique RPGs in part two!

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (15)
Pax_dsi_01
January 27, 2010
I owe a lot to Super Mario RPG. At the time I had no idea what RPG even meant (for whatever reason I thought it was referring to its isometric graphics, idiotic I know). I remember I tried Final Fantasy I a very long time ago without knowing a clue about it. It didn't impress my 5 year-old taste so I never gave it much thought there after. After experiencing Mario RPG start to finish, however, I had to play more like it. One day I rented Final Fantasy III/VI at my local Movie Gallery after reading the words RPG on the display box. The rental was for 1 day only for a $1 so I figured why the hell not. 15 hours of play time later I had to return the game and wait another week to rent it. Sure, the style was similar to Mario RPG, but the subject matter and game mechanics (random battles, no timed attacks to name a few) were quite jarring. Still I had fun and eagerly waited till I could rent it again. Suffice to say, I was hooked on JRPGs from there after. God, what time sinks, but I sure do love every moment of most of them.
Brett_new_profile
January 27, 2010
I love this article, Brian. I don't know if I'd call myself a JRPG hater, but at a certain point they've all bled together for me. Thanks for singling out the ones that stand out from the pack!
Default_picture
January 27, 2010
Thanks for the recommendations. I am definitely a JRPG hater, but the games you picked out look really interesting. I'll just have to take a look...
Default_picture
January 27, 2010
I miss Super Mario RPG .. Now if a true sequel would come out
N712711743_851007_3478
January 28, 2010
I second Brett; this is a great article. I'm more of an RPG junkie, so I'm very curious as to what you think would pull in the haters. So far, so good; I especially applaud the stones it took adding Mother 3. I truly wish Nintendo would just put the damn thing on the DS and quit torturing it's fans. Patiently waiting for the next segment...
Jason_wilson
January 28, 2010
If this is for "RPG Haters," why is the guide full of only Japanese RPGs? Wouldn't you want to expose haters to the good the West has to offer as well?
Ragnaavatar2
January 28, 2010
Such a great article, that made me remember great moments in those games. I've had Terranigma for a while now sitting in a folder, so I guess it's due time I finally finish it. Thanks for the heads up! Oh, and I strongly disagree on Secret of Evermore. It may have JRPG roots, but it was developed in North America. Also, I find it boring as hell. ;D
Demian_-_bitmobbio
January 28, 2010
To be fair, Jason, it does specify 'JRPG' in the title...although someone could certainly do a version for non-J RPGs. Hint.
Default_picture
January 28, 2010
@Jason: This guide was meant for people who haven't enjoyed most JRPGs. I considered using JRPG twice in the title to be completely clear, but I thought it looked funny. And as for hater, I didn't mean that in a derogatory way -- I just meant for this article to be source of some unique JRPGs that people who don't normally like the genre might appreciate. I'd consider doing a Western RPG or MMO article too, but my knowledge is a bit lacking in those areas.
Default_picture
January 28, 2010
@Matt: Cool story! That's awesome that you liked Mario RPG enough to try out some other games in the genre. I found JRPG mechanics jarring at first too when I played Final Fantasy IV (my first RPG). @Brett: Thanks, glad you like it! @Jeremy: No problem, I'm glad it was helpful. I hope you enjoy some of these titles if you get the chance to check them out. @Toby: Me too. I was disappointed when Paper Mario was released instead of Mario RPG 2. Did you ever play the Mario & Luigi series? I felt that they captured the spirit of the original rather well. @Matthew: Thanks! I hope they'll eventually release it for DS as well. I'd definitely buy it. @Carlos: Thanks! Make sure you level up enough for the final boss, because that fight can take [i]forever[/i] otherwise. @Demian: If I can find the time to complete some more Western RPGs I'd like to write one.
Default_picture
January 28, 2010
@ brian, thanks for writing this compilation up - I've been trying to learn more about JRPGS - currently playing DragonQuest 8 - I can see how they're different to western RPGS and in my eyes, the process of leveling up and combat is the biggest difference between the two :-)
Dcswirlonly_bigger
January 28, 2010
Personally I would add [i]Final Fantasy XII[/i] to this list. If I were to sum the game up in one phrase it would be "Final Fantasy for people who don't like Final Fantasy." It purposely tried to get rid of a lot of the things people hate about JRPGs. By extension, you might also be able to apply this to all of Yasumi Matsuno's games, particularly [i]Vagrant Story[/i]. Its premise and gameplay are almost nothing like other JRPGs. Its premise, presentation, and art style resemble that of western RPGs more than JRPGs.
Img_20110311_100250
January 29, 2010
Facts: I don't enjoy JRPGs. I love Super Mario RPG and Mario & Luigi. Like, serious L-O-V-E. I will try Mother 3. Good day to you, sir!
Default_picture
March 18, 2010

Terranigma... the game that started my slow descent into the madness that is gaming fandom.

I can't believe I played it on an emulator 10-11 years ago.

Default_picture
March 19, 2010

@Guillaume: Wow, that's a long time ago! I'm glad I discovered it within the past couple years.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.