Separator

BYU Study: Gaming Will Make You A Loser

26583_1404714564368_1427496717_31101969_389938_n
Thursday, August 27, 2009

I was listening to the radio in the car on the way home, and all of a sudden, John Tesh was talking about this study from Brigham Young University that links video games to poor relationships with friends and family.

According to John Tesh, the study says that a group of 813 students from six different universities answered questions about their gaming habits and the qualities of their personal relationships. The study goes on to say that--

What? Why was I listening to John Tesh? We're not talking about me, OK? We need to focus.

The study (if you want to read the whole thing, it's available online) makes the following connections, among others.

 

1) Playing video games, especially violent titles, is "negatively related" to relationships with parents and friends.

2) The young women who played video games the most often had the lowest self-esteem.

3) People who play games are more likely to be involved in "risky behaviors" like binge drinking, drug abuse, and sexual promiscuity.

If you read that article that I linked to above, you'll see that the researchers themselves say that the connection is "modest."

So what's the big deal?

I think it's a bit more telling that they were surveying 20-year-old students; you could just as easily make a connection between preference in ice cream flavors and "risky behaviors" because at the end of the day, they are 20-year-old college students.

Do you know what I think causes people to have low self-esteem, fights with their parents, and a need to drink vast quantities of alcohol?Being in college.  According to the study, 90 percent of the students surveyed lived away from their parents, which means that it's a hell of a lot easier for them to go out drinking or bring somebody home or, heaven forbid, stay up all night playing video games.

Why do they do this?  Because they can.

Laura Walker, the co-author of the study, concludes, "It may be that young adults remove themselves from important social settings to play video games, or that people who already struggle with relationships are trying to find other ways to spend their time...[m]y guess is that it’s some of both and becomes circular." This makes sense at first, maybe, but it completely ignores the element of responsibility.

Let's say, for example, that you stayed up all night playing video games, so you slept during the day and missed class. You do this a number of times throughout the semester.  When you receive your grades, you find that you have not performed particularly well.

Congratulations, says the study. Your video game habit has affected your academic performance, just like I said it would.

Now let's say that you stay up all night watching MacGyver. You miss class; you come home; you spend the next night watching Star Trek. And so on. You get your grades, and they're terrible. Why are the grades bad? Because of TV Land?  Or because you failed to get your shit together?

I'm thinking it's the latter, and it should be no different for video games. The fact is that people who neglect one part of their lives to indulge another will see a decrease in quality in the neglected area. And a big part of what people learn in college is how to prioritize, how to set goals, and how to balance work and fun. In other words, college is where many people learn to be adults.

But it's also where many people drink and have a lot of sex, because that's pretty much what young people will do, if given half a chance.

* Bonus Strangeness: The article refers to "Project READY", and the study contains a link to Projectready.net. But if you click on that link, it's an ad portal. I'm not shouting conspiracy or anything; that's just kind of weird.

Oh, and there's only one mention of Project READY on the Internet, and its goal is not to examine the transition of young people to adulthood, but rather to help nontraditional Iowa students earn a high-school diploma.

Make what you will of this information.

 
Problem? Report this post
EVAN KILLHAM'S SPONSOR
Comments (12)
Default_picture
August 28, 2009
Wow and once again someone does a study and only picks out the gamers. Now I wish they would poll 813 non gamers and see what kind of answers they get.
26583_1404714564368_1427496717_31101969_389938_n
August 28, 2009
@Toby - Agreed, although that would be pretty difficult; games are pretty popular among people in that age group. But that's kind of the problem. Reading the study (which also examines Internet usage) it seems like a more reasonable conclusion is that it is a lot easier to get distracted now than ever before, and games are just one of those distractions. I see no reason to single it out, though; I've overheard enough conversations about Twilight to believe that it, too, is dealing some serious "damage."
Default_picture
August 28, 2009
@Evan you could even put harry potter into that same equation every time a book / movie or news came out during there first releases as well.
Jamespic4
August 28, 2009
[quote]3.) People who play games are more likely to be involved in "risky behaviors" like binge drinking, drug abuse, and sexual promiscuity.[/quote] What a shock that such a conclusion would come out of a university founded by a Mormon, and attended and staffed mostly by Mormons. No offense to Mormons, but I do have to ask the question. Are their strict rules governing these sorts of behaviors coloring the cultural climate at that particular university? I also have to question the veracity of anything coming out a university with 98% Mormon student body. A student body, who, if they follow their religious texts, believe that barley, cattle, wheat, pigs, chickens, horses, donkeys, and camels existed in the Americas before the arrival of Columbus in 1492. Also, Native Americans did not have a grasp on smelting technologies listed in the Book of Mormon during the time period covered in that text. Again, because of the religious content of this comment, I don't mean to pick on Mormons, and I have to say that people are free to believe what they believe. That doesn't mean that I have to listen to them though, particularly in the case of Brigham Young University.
Twitpic
August 28, 2009
These sort of studies aren't benefiting society in any way. Okay, so if it is true, big deal? Like you said, when you're at college you grow up a little bit because you have to find the right balance between work and fun.
26583_1404714564368_1427496717_31101969_389938_n
August 28, 2009
@James - It's a little touchy, yeah,and apparently the student co-author of the study hoped that the findings would "justify" his playing more Madden(?!). I don't want to make any accusations of a hidden agenda or anything; I just think it's the usual bad science mistaking correlation for causality.
26583_1404714564368_1427496717_31101969_389938_n
August 28, 2009
@Cosmo (may I call you "Cosmo"? It somehow makes more sense than calling you "J") - I think it's telling that the researchers say that the connection is "modest." For all intents and purposes, this says to me that they don't think there is a connection, but they had to conclude something. I think it's time to read this Penny Arcade strip again. [url]http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2006/4/12/[/url]
Lance_darnell
August 28, 2009
This is was fascinating stuff! So people with low self-esteem, people who are prone to violence, people who like to make love, drink and have fun play video games??? I wonder how much they paid to get that study done. I can help them out: [quote]People who drive cars play video games. Cars are dangerous. The video game driving simulators, because that's what they are, depict and encourage smashing into others cars. These people then go out driving after being encouraged to smash into other cars![/quote] Hire me Jack Thompson Dude! ;D
26583_1404714564368_1427496717_31101969_389938_n
August 28, 2009
Lance! Where have you been all day? Congratulations; you solved it. There is an alarming connection between wanting to have fun and playing video games. In related news, I have observed a similar connection between wanting to hear music and listening to the radio. And as soon as this grant money comes in I'm going to expose these findings to the world.
August 28, 2009
...and being a pedestrian is just a bad idea; you'll liqour stores, stores that sell cigarettes, and prostitutes, and they promote promiscuity, so that your kids find out about sex before they know what their genitalia is called and run the risk of getting some kind of STD!!! personally, i don't like Underoath very much, but there's this one song title i cannot forget: It's Dangerous Business Walking Out Your Front Door
Lance_darnell
August 28, 2009
Bitmob University----> Your questions are answered by frickin' geniuses!!!! Those who go to church have a higher rate of dying in a car crash due to more churches being built off major roads and highways!!! ;D
Lance_darnell
August 28, 2009
@Evan - Been neglecting my loved ones... ;) I'm with J Santos, just getting out of bed is bad for your health. We at Bitmob University know all!!!

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.