Call for sanity: Stop spending money on limited editions, cat helmets

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
Thursday, May 19, 2011
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Demian Linn

I've never been a huge special editions guy...although I do have a pair of Modern Warfare 2 night vision googles in the closet. Mint in box, naturally.

Does anyone actually have a girlfriend who would let them decorate the living room with this stuff?

I think I’ve finally gotten over shelling out ridiculous amounts of money just to feel like I’m special. It wasn’t easy; at the impressionable, faux-rebellious age of 16 I owned four copies of Chuck Palahniuk’s first novel Fight Club and two different editions of Reservoir Dogs. I was a sucker for "unique" packaging -- I’d gladly shell out an extra 10 bucks if I thought it would make my shelf display look hipper. In hindsight, the amount of money I could have saved myself is disgusting.

Epic Games recently announced the contents of the "Limited" and "Epic" editions of the highly anticipated Gears of War 3. The Limited edition, priced at a reasonable $80, comes in special packaging and includes a medal engraved with a multiplayer character code, some unique weapon skins, documents and mementos, and a C.O.G. flag. Not bad for an extra $20, right? Well, they’re willing to make you another deal. For a mere $150, you can net yourself a statuette and (sigh) art book. Interested? No?

We fanboys are suckers. A close friend of mine paid $150 for the Epic edition of Gears 3 months before he even had an inkling of what it would contain, bless his soul. I’m certainly not immune. I’ve already pre-ordered my limited edition of Skyrim, the contents of which are still a mystery. Video game merchants sure make it tough to say no: I’ve seen plenty of clueless parents suckered into buying collector’s editions for fear of accidentally purchasing the wrong version of the game for their child. Hell, I almost plunked down $80 for the Fallout: New Vegas collector’s edition, which includes poker chips and decks of cards. I never play poker. Ever.

 

The Halo series is particularly infamous for putting out some absurd special editions. Halo 3’s premium version was notorious for a poorly designed disc holder that led to faulty, unplayable games. The Legendary edition came with a replica Master Chief helmet, ridiculed for being a "cat helmet." The Legendary edition of Halo: Reach, priced at $150, came with a diorama of action figures featuring Noble Squad, some flaming multiplayer armor, and a bunch of in-universe artifacts revealing information easily found on Halopedia for free.

I hope you weren't thinking of playing with those. They don't detatch.

I’m not saying that statuettes, poker chips, war journals, concept art (sigh), and flaming armor aren’t cool things to have, but I am saying that they’re definitely not worth paying over twice the price of an already expensive product. (Although I will admit I really could use Modern Warfare 2’s night vision goggles to make evening bathroom trips more of an adventure.) Presumably we purchase these editions not because game sites posts un-boxing videos, but because we want to prove that we’re the ultimate fans of our favorite franchises. The truth is, though, that my favorite memories of Fallout 3 aren’t my Vault-Tec lunch box and Vault Boy bobble head -- rather, those memories are from actual time I spent playing the game.

A jack-in-the-box? Is it the 19th century? I'd rather have Ezio's hidden blade....

My suggestion: Instead of spending enough money to buy a game twice, downgrade and buy another game to make memories with! I promise that you won’t lose sleep because you didn’t get that Big Daddy figurine or the Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood jack-in-the-box. Maybe even use that extra theoretical cash to buy a strategy guide (but please, not the ridiculous hardcover editions). Or, yet another suggestion: You could, you know...pay bills. I think that’s what I’ll do.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (26)
Default_picture
May 18, 2011

I've yet to purchase a collector's/special edition, but then, I'm not much of a collector. I'm perfectly happy finishing a game without getting every trophy and achievement, and I could live without an overpriced statuette. I suppose there's a first time for everything...

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
May 18, 2011

No! You must continue to stand true!

230340423
May 18, 2011

I just bought the "collector's edition" of Metroid Prime Trilogy, but that's because it only comes in a collector's edition. Hell, I just couldn't believe I found it used at a Gamestop. Who in his right mind would trade that in? A chump, that's who.

Default_picture
May 18, 2011

I consider limited editions if they include in game stuff that I might consider using while playing the game. Flaming Spartan Helmet? No thank you. Adam Fenix? You know what?... I would use that if I had it. Do I 80 Dollars want it? We'll see.

Years ago, I recieved the special edition of Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers and it came with a Gollum statue and that thing is AWESOME. I still have it. I also recieved Assassins Creed II Limited Edition as a gift, and the Ezio statue was just alright... It was plastic, though... unlike the Gollum statue. Still, recieving them as gifts is pleasant.

Lolface
May 19, 2011

I'm not too big on collector's editions, but the Modern Warfare night vision goggles were pretty cool, and if there were ever a Splinter Cell limited edition with a pair of working Sam Fisher night vision goggles, I would be all over that.

Bitmob_photo
May 19, 2011

I like what Dark Souls is doing, where if you preorder you get a free upgrade to the collector's edition. I usually don't get CEs though, I just like the games.

Robsavillo
May 19, 2011

Yeah, me too. Also, Dark Souls' CE comes with something useful: a strategy guide!

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
May 19, 2011

I would have loved to play Demon's Souls. Alas, I do not have a PS3. I'm definitely going to pre-order Dark Souls for 360, though, if what you say is true.

Robsavillo
May 19, 2011

Matt, here's the Dark Souls preorder information.

Dscn0568_-_copy
May 19, 2011

I bought the Street Fighter 4 and Marvel vs. Capcom 3 limited editions. The Street Fighter one had a lot of content but most of it was mediocre except for the soundtrack CD. The Ties that Bind movie was really forgettable. I only bought the MVC3 one because it came with the DLC character codes I would have to pay for eventually anyway. At least the packaging is better then the original cover art.

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
May 19, 2011
Demian, are you telling me you have night vision goggles and you haven't tried them out?!
Sexy_beast
May 19, 2011

Little do most people know, Demian doesn't need to use them; he already can see in the dark.

His eyes do that glowing thing when you shine a light at them -- just like a cat...or el chupacabra.

Demian_-_bitmobbio
May 20, 2011

That's right, I haven't even tried them out yet. And Ryan's actually correct about one thing -- I'm the king of redeye in flash photos.

Default_picture
May 20, 2011
What's wrong with art books?!
Default_picture
May 20, 2011

Nothing, as long as they're done well! The tiny art books that came with games like Assassin's Creed 2 and Mass Effect 2 were jokes. 48 pages of size of a DVD case is no way to look at cool concept art! I just got a look at The Witcher 2's art book and the thing is great! About 200 full-sized pages of art and commentary.

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
May 20, 2011

Nothing's wrong with art books in general, but as John said below, a lot of them aren't up to snuff.

Default_picture
May 20, 2011
Yeah that I agree with. The art books that come with the WoW CEs are my favorite. The little ones are nice, but should be much better for the extra money.
Default_picture
May 20, 2011

I don't buy collector's editions to look like I'm an "ultimate fan", I buy them because they have cool stuff or extra pieces of gameplay. It all depends on what's inside and how much it costs. I made the mistake of buying the AC2 collector's edition. While the statue was neat, the "DLC" ended up being an unlock code for content already on the disc. Not worth $100. I passed on Brotherhood's collector's edition. I'm <i>eventually</i> going to get The Witcher 2's collector edition. It has an awesome art book, a solid bust (no really), soundtrack, making of DVD, very cool set of D6s with etched Roman numerals, and some other "meh" things like playing cards and stickers. Not worth the asking price of $130, but since I have it on hold indefinitely, and I haven't even started the first game anyway, I can afford to wait for the price to drop. :)

Avatarrob
May 20, 2011

I haven't bought a Collector's Edition since FFXII, and that was only because it was in a shiny metal case for $1 more than the standard version.

To be honest, I miss the days of the old Atlus releases where there wasn't a standard edition. Every copy came with the random goodies; cloth maps, trinkets, soundtracks and all manner of other crap to be shoved back in the box. Memories!

Default_picture
May 20, 2011

Agreed. There used to be a time when the "collector's edition" was the standard and it had some really nice stuff in it that could also be used while playing the game and the game was at most $10-$20 over the typical price. Now it's almost triple the price for a 3" foam rubber figurine.

Shoe_headshot_-_square
May 20, 2011

I like your suggestion at the end...a very common-sense way to look at it. I do get some "super" editions from being in press, like a Black Ops R/C car that I'm not sure what to do with...and the aforementioned night-vision goggles. But I'm not buying so many myself anymore. Agreed...they just take up too much space. I am a sucker for nice tin cases, though. And for some series like Mass Effect, I'll probably continue getting the fat-tin edition, just so all of them look nice together on my rack!

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
May 20, 2011

I, too, am a sucker for a tin case. It was right around the time that the Force Unleashed 2 came out when I realized that if all I'm getting other than the tin case is (in TFU2's case) a flash drive with game-related desktop wallpapers and a character skin I won't use, I'll just pass. But the temptation is still there...

Default_picture
May 20, 2011

I don't buy special editions of games unless they come with something I actually value (a soundtrack, bonus games, etc.) but I'm a fan of them in general.  It's a way for folks to give more money for the items they like, and in a way, they help subsidize the mass market audience.  If anything, more devs should take note of Atlus (and Working Designs, before them) and create truly "special" editions. 

It doesn't bother me if other people want to pay a premium for cat vision goggle helmets.

167586_10100384558299005_12462218_61862628_780210_n
May 20, 2011

Not to sound like a fearmonger, but if publishers see that we're willing to pay ridiculous amounts of money for cheap, foreign-made trinkets, it just might start to catch on and drag down the quality of collector's editions in general.

Default_picture
May 20, 2011

That's a valid concern, Matt, and it's frustrating to see the sort of garbage that attempts to pass itself off as a special edition bonus.

However, publishers already know that people are willing to pay ridiculous amounts of money for cheap trinkets.  And I believe value is something only the individual purchaser can determine, unless folks really think a "Collector's" edition is going to be worth money down the line for resale. 

I preordered the new Alice game mainly because it came with the original.  Then again, I did so at Toys R Us for $45 and I used a $20 credit from some promotion that I had to get rid of...so I'm pretty bad at giving publishers extra money (unless the new game turns out to be horrible). 

But really, if folks aren't wasting their money on things I like, I imagine they'll find some other hole in which to sink it. 

Default_picture
May 23, 2011

I was almost going to buy the limited edition of SF4 but after thinking back and forth on it, I said no.  I don't regret it at all because SSF4 came out afterwards.  I was also able to get the little figure and headband that comes with the game for free too.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.