Ys Seven Coding Grievance

Avi2
Monday, August 16, 2010

Author's note: This was sent today at 9:35 AM, GMT+1 time. The address was taken out for privacy reasons. Otherwise, this mail was actually sent towards comments@xseedgames.com in this entirety with the title "Ys Seven Gripe.", with minor adjustments to fit editorial purposes. Feel free to follow up on that example, if you agree with the statements below. Thank you.


 

16 August 2010



Dear developers of Ys,

I don't usually do this sort of grievance mailing to hard working people, but I'm considerably upset at the moment.

You see, I've been looking out for the day that Ys Seven would come out since your announcements to continue the series and bring more RPG's to the PSP system after so long. This was more than exponentially heightened, once I saw the sublime collector's edition you had planned for the game. Before watching any actual footage, I knew this would be one of the only games ever to convince me to follow the current generations of games.

I'm a 26 year old, that has been picking up games on Atari 2600 since I was 3. Usually, I'm an oldschool gamer that grew up on SNES and Master System, which is why I'm playing the original Ys right this moment. Whether good game or not, this would be the only collector's edition I would purchase in over a decade, because it was just marvellously constructed. Not only that, it would also be the first current gen title I would purchase on launch day in over a decade as well.

 


My adult Master System with genuine Ys copy.

 

Now, a day before release, I've searched far and wide and have come to the realization that not only the collector's edition will solely be available in the North American region, but will also be coded for that region. In addition that this leaves me utterly wanting, I would not be able to play it right here in Europe, even if I would go completely out of my way to import an edition (setting me back immensely in shipping). I find myself offended by this arrangement, as I had set my hopes for this wonderful collector's edition a long time ago, relatively.

By this mail I therefore wish to express that offence and also my lack of understanding on the matter. I just cannot see why Europe isn't a viable market for you to release your product, where North America is. I assure you we have a considerable large base market for both PSP and RPG games here as well. Even so, I would've gladly helped rally the online and mouth to mouth campaign for the promotion of this; as I did to this day. Sadly, I cannot further this effort and am now leaving to spread my grievances about this, where I first was very optimistic. I do not believe in speaking for a majority, but I do believe I'm only one of many consumers duped by this. In my city alone, I understand there is a following in the thousands for RPG's and even more for PSP games in general, as we're a university city. This alone, and the fact I live mere yards away from the city "nerd shop", would've made the easiest and most effective word of mouth operation I could imagine, spreading like wildfire.

I hope you will consider this "faux pas" for further ventures of your merchandise. For now, I must regretfully abandon any following and optimism about your works. Something I find shameful, as I believe you do your best to complete a quality product. I disclose to you my full name and address, as I do not want to viewed as merely destructively criticising your projects. I communicate this to you in all sincerity. It is my hope this will get read and noted for future reference.

Dearly disappointed,
Daav Valentaten

 
Problem? Report this post
DAAV 'PUKE' VALENTATEN'S SPONSOR
Comments (3)
Default_picture
August 16, 2010

Possibly because Xseed is a US Publisher/Translator and doesn't really have contacts with any of the games stores in Europe whatsoever. They were able to talk to SCEE about getting it available for download over there, but building a distribution network in a country half-way around the world isn't the easiest thing in the world.

It's not like Falcom, the company making Ys7, is the one doing the publishing. They just made it available for companies to translate and bring over to other countries, and no publisher or translator in Europe has expressed interest. 

I do find it odd that it would be region coding. Would that be only the second PSP title ever to be region coded? I suppose what you would have to do is import the collectors edition, then buy the downloadable version. Or you could have someone in the US buy the collectors edition, sell the UMD copy, and ship the rest to you.

Avi2
August 16, 2010

Well, they have distribution through their site affiliated with Gamestop and we have Gamestops in Europe, so I find it hard to believe they have no starting distribution point. And that's only one of so many. Even as import stores, there are several dozens in my country alone (might not be well known, but they're still there AND reach out themselves). And It is region (NTSC) coded unfortunately. Going through all the extensive buying trading, repackaging and shipping once more via via seems a bit overly harsh just to be able to enjoy 1 game.

Default_picture
August 16, 2010

I don't think we know all of the ins and outs of their distribution deal with Gamestop. It's quite possible that Gamestop in Europe must be negotiated separately from Gamestop in the US. Not to mention that if it's region locked to North America then it would mean stamping an entire new run of UMD discs. Plus there may be requirements with the EU about what languages must be supported to sell physically in stores. Most of the west coast translators only release their games in English and French.

It took Xseed a long time to get Falcom to let them localize it, I suspect that means that Falcom had reservations about the price, or about reimportation to Japan. I would bet that they probably restricted it to NA so that Falcom didn't have to worry about people reimporting stuff back to Japan... It looks like the price for Ys Seven in japan is $10 more than the collectors edition is here... and that's just for the regular release.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.