Legitimate Female Game Journalists Deserve Our Respect

Default_picture
Saturday, January 30, 2010

Editor's note: Brian is tired of seeing eye candy getting more clicks on game sites than talented female game journalists. Does the enthusiast press have a sexism problem? Or is it the audience that's sexist? -Jason


Recently, I came across a disturbing statement directed toward a female game journalist. I won't mention who initiated this attack or which woman was the victim of this cruel statement, but it bothered me enough to write about an issue that has long concerned me: the portrayal and treatment of women in game journalism.

A female game journalist's response to this derogatory comment regarding her appearance reminded me of the scrutiny females are under in this medium. I'm no feminist, and I've probably even made the occasional sexist remark, but it disturbs me that female game journalists are often valued more for their looks than their knowledge of games and ability to write.

The field has exceptions of course -- Bitmob, EGM, 1UP, Gamasutra, Gamespot, and GamePro have all had a number of valued female staff and freelance writers -- but sadly, a number of other outlets who use "attractive" females to capture the attention of teenage males. Don't get me wrong -- I'm not against women who wear lots of makeup and show off their silicone, but when outlets use women solely for their appearance instead of their knowledge, things have gone too far.

 

If I was an intelligent female that worked for a video game publication, I'd feel insulted when women that only have a teaspoon of my knowledge get in front of a camera with a low-cut shirt and pretend to know about video games. Women who actually care about video games are the ones who truly deserve respect since they obtained their position with their brainpower and unique contributions they've brought to the game industry.

I find it especially annoying that these women are typically ignored in favor of bimbos since they overcame so many hardships to obtain their dream career. As someone who's been stereotyped for my interest in video games the majority of my life, I can understand how hard it must have been for many of these women to enter a field they were probably told was "just for boys." Even before beginning their writing careers, many of these journalists were probably ridiculed for their interest in games -- especially if they weren't fortunate enough to be prom queens.

Even with the past behind them, it must be incredibly insulting to get on a video feature and then get bashed in the comments section for not sharing Brittney Spears' plastic-like exterior. If certain readers of game sites don't find a particular journalist attractive, they should keep it to themselves instead of making an insulting comment that could keep female game gurus from feeling comfortable on camera.

Besides, if these guys frequent game sites in the hopes of seeing breasts for the first time, their lives would be better spent opening a Playboy or going to one of the trillions of websites designed to meet their needs. Oh, and just for the record, I think these juvenile posters are upset because they could never get a quality female game journalist to even talk to them.

I didn't write this article in the hopes of creating a female fan base -- I'm just tired of the female "game journalists" who like to model naked getting all of the attention. The enthusiast press features number of talented female game journalists who create thought-provoking articles, so it irritates me when they're ignored in favor of camera-whores who treat their game consoles like sex toys.

How do we resolve this problem? By recognizing the contributions of passionate female game writers and ignoring women who seem like they'd be more at home in a wet T-shirt contest.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (35)
Alexemmy
January 28, 2010
Gurl gamerz r hawt.
Default_picture
January 28, 2010
Nice article, I agree with how you feel. Unfortunately, the bimbos are always going to be with us (so sayeth marketing) but at least the number of legitimate journalists are increasing. It's a hard row to hoe. I have incredible respect for Morgan Webb and consider her an intelligent game journalist, but after her photoshoot/columns in a popular men's magazine it was hard to look at her the same way. But what would you do? You're a media personality, you need exposure. Jobs like that can give you more mass-market appeal. Unfortunately, when you do spreads like that people tend to think that you got your job simply because you are attractive rather than talented. It reminds me of one of my wife's favorite sayings about women: "You're nothing if you're pretty and you're nothing if you're not."
Default_picture
January 28, 2010
I couldn't agree more. Unfortunately, video games are marketed to the male demographic, and in order to sell, they go with what will catch their attention. That just happens to be pretty women. Of course, just because you're pretty doesn't mean that you're not legitimately interested in video games, but unfortunately the majority are not.
Jason_wilson
January 28, 2010
The enthusiast press isn't the only place where women struggle for respect in journalism. Many women encountered hostility as they broke into the ranks of male-dominated sports journalism. I've never worked at a sports desk that employed women -- I did work at one where the previous sports editor was a woman, but to be honest, she was more of a man that most males, and I wonder if she had to be that way in order to make it in the industry. I enjoy hearing from varied voices -- and that's one of the issues with the enthusiast press. How many blacks and Latinos are out there covering games from a different perspective than whites and Asians? How many female voices are out there? Some may dismiss journalism's attempts to get varied voices as just being politically correct, but people from different backgrounds truly have something different and interesting to say. And I want to hear it.
Img_20100902_162803
January 28, 2010
Hispanic causing panic on bitmob right here.
Default_picture
January 29, 2010
It's not simply that underinformed pretty women get the good spots, it's that the attractive informed women get valued for their looks as much as their minds. Hence we get Webb and Munn photospreads - both knowledgeable nerds, but no one is craving a Sessler or Hsu spread in GQ, right? So there is pressure for the women to become models or something as well as journalists. Though I'm sure there is some measure of empowerment there - any smart woman who wants to be a model has every right to - it's also in many ways a fulfillment of the male nerd fantasy; that the pretty cheerleader is also a secret gamer and you can cheat code your way into her heart.
Mikeshadesbitmob0611
January 29, 2010
It's not what you know, it's who you know that gets you ahead. It's a lot easier to know people when you're physically attractive.
Default_picture
January 29, 2010
Can't help but agree with the poster above that attractiveness will get you ahead - even if it's not intentional. Let's not kid ourselves - we all know that being attractive is a plus no matter what industry you are in. If you're a top female physicist who is mildly attractive - you're going to be known as "the hot physicist". Cringe all you want, but that is how they will be perceived and marketed. As for female game journalists, a good number of them out there are definitely legit. They know their stuff and they've probably headshotted a fair number of their male audience in Halo. If they promote themselves as knowledgeable, witty, insightful and clever - that's how they will win fans... Fans of [i]that[/i] sort. As for the attractive females who promote themselves as such, they will win fans of [i]that[/i]sort. Inevitably, there will be a market for sexy-gamer-girls so craved by stereotypical nerdy-horny-gamer-boys. And so, there will be sexy-gamer-girls providing that product. It's not wrong. They're fulfilling the needs of a group of people out there and if they are doing a good job - hey, who is to say that's a bad thing? Just like not all of us will be fans of the female-gamers who would say something along the lines of, "Like, OMG I named my Star Trek Online ship the USS 2sexy4u and my crew wears pink latex!", Not everyone will be fans of the straight-edge take-me-seriously journalists, either. We can only hope they will join our side someday.
Lance_darnell
January 29, 2010
@Troy - I WANT Shoe and Demian in GQ right now!!!! Great article, Brian! As soon as video games become "cool" there was bound to be women associated with video games in some way or another, taking their clothes off! Now back to GQ....
Default_picture
January 29, 2010
This is why I appreciate people like Tina Sanchez, Leigh (sp?) Alexander, and numerous other women of all shapes, sizes, personalities, and ideologies that help populate the games journalism field. While I understand seeing people as sexual beings as an instinctive first thought on someone newly met, as we are still only "animals", it's important to remember that people are more than just their outer appearances. Also, anyone find this AA ad funny while reading the article? I did :p ! [url]http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2711/4317388166_55df81973e_b.jpg[/url]
Fitocrop
January 29, 2010
[quote]"...no one is craving a Sessler or Hsu spread in GQ, right?"[/quote] lol :D This seems to happen to women not only in gaming-journalism but in the gaming industry in general. Take Assasin's Creed producer Jade Raymond as an example. I'm pretty sure UBISOFT was aware of the advantages of having her in every single video-interview for the release of that game. Fanboyism flamed up and eventually she got burnt by some jerk that made and incredibly distasteful and derogatory comic strip about her and uploaded it to the internet. Sad, sad stuff.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
I think the dignity of the industry relies on the dignity of the people who work in it. If female journalists aren't hired for their knowledge and writing but for their appearance, people outside the industry will look down upon it. Sure, hot ladies will attract readers, but so will the industry's detractors.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
@Michael: [quote]It's not what you know, it's who you know that gets you ahead. It's a lot easier to know people when you're physically attractive. [/quote] I agree with that statement, and that's one of the things I hate most about our job market. I think companies often make mistakes when they hire people they know over qualified individuals.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
Wait, girls play video games?
Mikeshadesbitmob0611
January 30, 2010
Oh, I didn't say it was a good thing. It's just how things are.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
@Michael: I thought that's what you were saying (sorry if my comment sounded like an attack).
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
I hope you're not saying that attractive girls can't be gamers too. Judge a girl's passion of gaming through her work and her involvement in the industry, not on how low cut her shirt is. I disagree with Gabriel's comment about Morgan Webb in men's magazines and how he has lost respect for her because of it. Girls are different than boys b/c we like to be pretty, we like putting on lingerie and a bikini that makes us feel sexy. So why is it that just because Morgan Webb took photos in these outfits it makes you lose respect for her? Did the bikini make her care any less about games? Also, some of these girls, like myself, are models on the side. So does that mean I can't like games or I can't know about games just? I work my ass off in this industry, and I want people to look at my work and judge me on that - not on my wardrobe choice. All in all. You wanna know if a hot chick in front of a camera knows her games? Look at her past work. Most girls in these videos have never even written a post on their personal blogs about gaming, that's a sure sign that they don't give a damn. But some of these girls do care, some of them are very active the gaming community and they are hot enough to be models. We can play games and look cute while doing it.
Shoe_headshot_-_square
January 30, 2010
Question for anyone: James Mielke, former Editor in Chief of EGM, used to model. Does that mean he knows less about games now that you know that?
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
@Raychul: My intent wasn't to hate on attractive girls and I also didn't mean to say the knowledgeable writers I was referring to are unattractive. Basically, I was just upset that some companies choose to hire attractive women who know very little about games instead of intelligent female gamers who can either be attractive, unattractive, or anywhere in between. As for Morgan Webb, I'm not sure if she's an expert on games, but she wasn't one of the women I was referring to. I also wasn't trying to dis you, and actually liked the GOTY awards video you did with Shoe. Anyway, I hope that makes what I was trying to say a little more clear.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
@Dan: Ha, I actually just discovered that. And I really didn't mean to hate on people that model or attractive. What I was disappointed with is when certain companies focus exclusively on these types of girls and hire them over someone who may be a little less attractive, but more knowledgeable about games.
Shoe_headshot_-_square
January 30, 2010
[quote]It's a lot easier to know people when you're physically attractive.[/quote] I agree with that! That's why my downstairs grocery-store owner says hi to me when I walk in. I'm pretty sure it's because I'm physically attractive.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
@Brian - Oh I totally agree. It drives me crazy too. I hate when I see a girl getting credited and marketed as a "true girl gamer" yet the chick doesn't know the difference between an Xbox and a GameCube. I wish more people demanded "real gamer girls", and didn't settle for whatever hottie that certain company gives them. But I also wish people didn't discredit a girl just because she's attractive.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
@Raychul I wasn't saying that I lost respect for her--I'm a huge fan. She's funny, insightful, and obviously loves games. I was just disappointed that the industry works in such a way that she has to do photoshoots in skimpy clothes instead of a normal shot. Like it or not, if you have a picture of yourself in your underwear next to your article people aren't going to look at you the same way. I was simply trying to comment on the thin line many women in this industry have to ride. That's why I put in my wife's comment--you're damned if you do and damned if you don't. No loss of respect here.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
Talent is talent...is shines through. At least I hope it does. I really don't have much else to fall back on.
Image2496
January 30, 2010
[b]Jade Raymond[/b], I have a story about her. We were in line to play Assassin's Creed for the first time here in London at an event in the HMV. I was really excited to play the game, but many male gamers there were more excited just to see Jade and take a picture with her. What creeped me out though, was one person talked to me and my friend how he wanted to you-know-what to her. He mentioned he had a girlfriend, but that he'd drop her if he could get with Ms. Raymond. It was bloody creepy, and he said he had rape fantasies about her, which I couldn't believe and was just gobsmacked. We gave him a telling to, that she should be respected, not ogled and idolised like that. He was like "whatever" like it's ok to say stuff like that. We never saw him again, and hope not to. I know he probably wasn't serious, but man.
100_0005
January 30, 2010
This was an excellent and insightful post, plus it's great to see the ladies in here get passionate about this debate. I have no problem with a woman using her body however she wishes in the game industry as long she is a legitimate enthusiast as well. Nothing sexier than receiving a beat down from a lady in your favorite game.
Untitled
January 30, 2010
Great article Brian. I couldn't agree more. Women have just as much to offer in the field as men do, in some cases more so. @Jasmine don't sell yourself short.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
I usually go straight to the female reviews oddly. In EGM Jen Tsao only lead me wrong on ONE game. I hated Animal Crossing. I bought almost any game she gave an 8 or higher I bought it, even if I didn't know it. Since she left, and EGM was taken upstate to live on a farm. (Thats what happened, right?) I have not known what to what to buy. I just wish most Magazines (Yeah I still read Magazines, because it is awkward to take the lappy in the bathroom) had more than the one Token "GURL GAMER!" reviewer.
N752290354_2283
January 30, 2010
It really is a shame that looks have any effect on how we view things in the gaming world. It's a terrible double standard too as no one seems to give two craps whether a male games journalist is attractive or not. Personally I don't care either way, if someone has something interesting and insightful to say, male or female then I'm interested.
Default_picture
January 30, 2010
utterly fantastic article. i couldn't agree more with you. i remember Jen Tsao's reviews in EGM were pretty brutal, but real honest. a different perspective is always good to hear. Especially Kat Bailey's perspective on Demons' Souls. She sold me on the game!
Mikeshadesbitmob0611
January 30, 2010
@Shoe: Could be! You should ask him next time you're down there. Even guys like to feel attractive once in awhile :P
Default_picture
January 31, 2010
[quote]James Mielke, former Editor in Chief of EGM, used to model. Does that mean he knows less about games now that you know that?[/quote] Pics or it didn't happen (no homo)!
Jason_wilson
January 31, 2010
[quote]I just wish most Magazines (Yeah I still read Magazines, because it is awkward to take the lappy in the bathroom) had more than the one Token "GURL GAMER!" reviewer. [/quote] Jason: (Note: I've edited her work, so I may be biased) Heidi Kemps is among the freelance reviewers for GamePro, and she wrote two very interesting reviews in its March 2010 issue (along with a fantastic prerelease piece on Final Fantasy 13).
Default_picture
January 31, 2010
I think I know which statement prompted you to write this article and I can't blame you. It was one of the most vile, disgusting things I've seen on that community and I'm surprised the user is still allowed to post there freely. I understand what you are trying to say as well. People definitely shouldn't misinterpret this article as blasting attractive people. Beauty and Knowledge are not mutually exclusive. However, I noticed that some of the large outlets you left out of your list are the same ones that come to mind when I think of manufactured hosts with questionable talent hired to look good in front of a camera. Oh, and I know people hated the "new" E3 that was tried, but booth babes and large, flashy shows, don't need to be so intertwined either. I'm sure the industry could put on a nice show with lots of energy without trying to show more skin than the booth to the side.
Default_picture
April 02, 2012

I'm really glad people are starting to realize this. I have wanted nothing more than to work with video games in some way or another since i was a little girl. To see some random bimbo get the job in a heartbeat, rather than the dedicated female gamer really touches a nerve for me. I'd like to think im one of the "good looking" female gamers who actually knows what the hell shes talking about. Still i know im not the best looking person in the entire world, and there will more than likely be some model given the job over the experianced female gamers.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.