Separator

The New Age of Strategy Guides and Online Walkthroughs

Shoe_headshot_-_square
Tuesday, February 02, 2010

Pry yourself away from that black-and-white, rabbit-eared, wood-grained TV set of yours for a sec. Did you know the world of strategy guides and user-created walkthroughs has come a long ways since the days of traditional maps and the ASCII ways of GameFAQs.com?

 

Click for a larger view.


Guiding light

You've likely seen collector's edition strategy books whose production costs probably rival the very games they're covering. But aggressive publishers are looking to add value wherever possible, knowing full well the type of competition they're facing online. And the type of goods they're offering, you just can't find on the Internet.

Traditionally, guide publishers like Prima Games and BradyGames always had the advantage of pre-release access to the games and the developers, so gamers are always getting the most official, most accurate information possible at the perfect time: day one. "That map of the Capital Wasteland alone took a month to plot," says David Hodgson, author and creative consultant at Prima, on his Fallout 3 book. "Having it available to readers at launch made the guide more valuable."

Yet it seems most gamers still prefer the ease (and price) of free online help. In an informal poll, 73% of gamers preferred Internet sources like GameFAQs to traditional guides. The print companies, however, have no plans to fall behind the evolutionary curve. "[Prima is putting] greater emphasis on content deemed helpful that perhaps wasn't historically offered," says Hodgson, "such as Xbox Live strategy videos, interactive maps, and the like."

Physical supplements help as well. Brady's recent Modern Warfare 2 book came with The Big Fold, a laminated tri-fold multiplayer map pack that you can prop up (or hang up) and write on with a dry-erase marker. The tactical possibilities can give online players a distinct advantage -- if the mocking from roommates and girlfriends doesn't prove to be too much of a distraction....

In future Big Folds, you can expect maps with weapon and health pickups, move lists for fighting games, playbooks for sports titles, and more.

Video, images, and color...meet FAQs

While many professional websites offer full guides now, GameFAQs and Wikia Gaming are the de facto destinations for ones created by the community. Newcomer PlayHaven is hoping to crack that market by offering some of the friendliest authoring tools around -- with drag-and-drop ease, users can create full-color walkthroughs with text, screenshots, videos, and captions.

PlayHaven guides look great for being community-made, especially next to the typewriter aesthetics of GameFAQs. But it's going to be a while before search engines start ranking PlayHaven links high enough for Googlers to notice. Plus, gamers are just used to going to GameFAQs first, and that won't be changing overnight.

With the success of GameFAQs and Wikia, as well as up-and-comers like PlayHaven, it may seem like strategy books are slowly falling behind, interactivity or not.

Hodgson, however, doesn't think so: "I know it's strange, but there's still a large audience for printed books, and not just for toilet reading. Ironically, some of the information in books is easier to get to than online Wikis. Personally, nothing beats flipping through a weighty guide book, though."


Want to try out a Modern Warfare 2 Big Fold for yourself? For some reason, the company sent us three of them when we wanted to check one out, maybe thinking we have online friends to play with. We don't, so they're yours. Just leave a comment below, and we'll pick three of you at random to send these to.

The usual rules apply: You must be registered on Bitmob with your FULL and REAL name, as well as a legit email address where we can contact you at. Continental U.S. only (sorry, we're cheap!). Void where prohibited.

 
Problem? Report this post
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (23)
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
It's been a long time since I've purchased a professionally produced strategy guide (Final Fantasy VIII), and that's mostly because of the convenience and free nature of Gamefaqs. Also, I enjoy completing games on my own, so I only like resorting to FAQs after I've completed the game for secrets or when a certain annoying puzzle or boss is giving me a lot of trouble. Another good source for online guides is Youtube. Shortly after Lost Odyssey was released, I noticed that there was a full video guide, which much have taken forever considering that game has between 60-100 hours worth of content. Still, despite the free nature of online guides, I'm a sucker for printed guides with great artwork and humor. That's one of the reasons I purchased the Mother 3 fan guide.
Bitmob_photo
February 02, 2010
I think guides should be built into the games themselves, or at least include better ways to track collectibles and quests so that a guide wouldn't even be necessary. I'm at the point where if I have to turn to a guide for help, then it's because the game did something wrong.
Waahhninja
February 02, 2010
I buy guides for games I know I'll be spending a LOT of time on. I don't use them to ruin the story or prepare me for a surprise around a corner. it's nice to have an easily-reachable, handy book of maps, weapon lists, locations and character guides. My Fallout 3 and Bioshock guides got a lot of use in some parts but for hours at a time they'd sit on the stack. They're just plain USEFUL. I can go online for some games if I need help (Lord knows I used the wikia for Borderlands and Dragon Age just to see if I should dump a certain weapon or quest) but the big daddies of time-sucking sometimes get easier with a few pages of well-written words and descriptive pictures.
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
I know that, for my kids, watching walkthroughs on YouTube has often become the de facto solution for any "tough spot" in a game. Although they may spend more time searching the service for the right video, I have to admit that it's hard to beat the immediate, direct demonstration of "what to do," especially having read some of the tortuous descriptions of navigation in some of GameFAQS's works. Personally, I am a fan of strategy guides simply for the reason that they give me a nice, printed companion piece to my game purchase. It's really the same reason that I loathe buying a game without the manual, though I very rarely RTFM. Once again I have to give a memorial shout-out to Versus Books. Everyone names Prima and Brady in strategy guides, because Versus somehow is long gone, but for the longest time they put out guides way superior to the work Prima and Brady did. When Prima was content to generate a guide that was 90% screenshots, Versus always seem to contain custom maps. For some reason, Versus guides were shelved as periodicals, and never had an ISBN (International Standard Book Number), which makes them much harder to order than older Prima and Brady guides. I would love to hear any stories about what happened to them. Rest in Peace, Versus Books!
Pax_dsi_01
February 02, 2010
I have to side with online guides. In Metal Gear Solid, for example, how would I have been able to know what Meryl's codec frequency is if I didn't have the box? When the only options available are to wait for the rental store to open so I can peek at the box, go out and buy the strategy guide, or to just hop on the computer and look online at game faqs, I'm going to use whatever is the most expedient. It is so much easier to find the answer for one question online than having to buy a guide I will probably only use once. I would buy them if guides offered more in terms of a packaged deal as stated above, but they need to advertise such things clearly or I won't be interested.
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
All I'm going to say is that I'm glad the online-content experiment in the Final Fantasy IX strategy guide (if it could even be called that) has never since been retried.
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
@ Chris Davidson- That's a really cool idea, I wonder if it would be possible for Prima or another strategy guide company to make deals with Publishers to develop DLC guide plugins that you could actually access while in game. I know I'd probably buy them over paper guides due to convenience and the amount of gaming I do at night. My purchasing of strategy guides has really diminished in the last few years, partially due to the ease of use and affordability of online guides and partially due to the increase in game costs. I'm not complaining about how expensive games have become in the last few years, and part of it is my own fault as I'm a sucker for the various special editions which seem to come out with every game that releases now. But due to the extra cost of purchasing said special editions it would be nigh impossible to convince my wife that I should be spending an additional $20-$30 per game on the accompanying strategy guides. Another thing that I've noticed in the last few guides I have purchased is the amount of errors that were in them. With my LBP guide I spent hours looking for certain hidden bubbles that weren't actually where the guide said they were. It's a minor complaint but when I spent $20 on a guide to help me on a game I didn't expect to encounter errors.
Waahhninja
February 02, 2010
@Kai What is the experiment you speak of? Never heard of it.
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
I also bought the Fallout 3 guide because I knew it would get extensive use; I even bought the Collector's Edition. For most games, though, GameFAQs and the like are enough to get me through any tough spots, or to help me find all those damn collectibles. I had no idea about the Big Folds. They could be somewhat handy.
Photo_159
February 02, 2010
Man I have always just read strategy guides when I know I am not going to play a game but I want to know what it would have been like. I had just beat FF7 but then my mom got my report card and I was grounded from video games. So I bought a FF7 strategy guide and read that thing at school... but then I ended up playing through the whole game again cause I missed a bunch of stuff the first time through. I finally figured it out. I think the Mob Bosses are using the American Apparel adds to keep our articles at a manageable length... I swear I tried to read the end of this article like four times... hold on let me try again... 5 times and I can't do it... I have no idea what that fine print says. wait wait... Yes. I would like to try out a big fold.
Redeye
February 02, 2010
I would be more interested in more active help with games then a print guide as it is. Any game that I need help in information wise I either only need 1 or 2 details that are easily got online and then everything else I can figure out myself. Where I really need help is execution and high level play in complex games like fighting games. Things a guide would do jack to help me with, so it would be more like I need a game tutor. Lord knows anyone who would offer that much for a service would charge more then I would be willing to pay for it too. Ah, life.
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
I'd be more than glad to take one of those MW2 Big Folds off your hands, Bitmob! :)
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
My daughter would love a big fold since I am banned from MW2. Cheats and strategy's have come a long way.
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
Anyone know where you get these big folders at? I need to get my hands on this MW2 map.
37893_1338936035999_1309080061_30825631_6290042_n
February 02, 2010
for me at least, this is a problem with the internet. once i get a taste of something for free (online FAQ's, Hulu, Pandora,) i can't seem to justify paying for it. sure, the quality of the online walkthroughs are low, but i can't get passed paying an extra 25% to play a game "the right way."
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
Hope the game guide companies will start innovating more and produce maybe a hybrid of game guides with special access online-wise for more or updated content. (especially if there's dlc)
Photo_1
February 02, 2010
I'd like to win one of these tri-fold guides. Sounds cool! I am a big user of GameFaqs. I would have to say it helped immensely when I was playing The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening. Those puzzles were intense when I was a kid!
Default_picture
February 02, 2010
My wife is getting her Nook very soon (she got it for her birthday), and with it, and the Kindle, and the upcoming iPad, seems there might be a new market for digital-book versions of strategy guides that instantly get updates to correct error or add new chapters when DLC becomes available. iPad version could include handy full-color maps! My son is already using his iPod Touch for instant GameFAQs and YouTube walkthrough access while we're sitting right at the console...
Normal_f3c8726ca7d523c031f09eb7d4e54430
February 02, 2010
I like getting strategy guides because I think they're fun to read. Also, I'd like to mention that GiantBomb.com has a great guide editing feature. Here's an example of what it's capable of: [url]http://www.giantbomb.com/guides/mass-effect-2-megaguide/1488/[/url]
Shoe_headshot_-_square
February 02, 2010
For those of you who are asking: The Big Folds are packed in with other strategy guides. So far, just Modern Warfare 2, but more are on their way.
February 03, 2010
Interesting story. I've always felt the need to flip through the strategy guides in Gamestop or at the end of the video game isle in K-Mart but I've never bought one before. I just wish that more games would include nice map posters in the game box.
Shoe_headshot_-_square
February 15, 2010
Congrats Brian Shirk, Jordan Vincent, and Toby Davis. Drew your names at random, so I'll be sending you a Big Fold.
February 20, 2010
Just wanted to say a public thanks for the swag!

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.