Separator
Has Gaming Desensitized Us to Gore and Blood?
Default_picture
Monday, October 05, 2009

Editor's note: When it comes to blood and gore, I'm a wimp. My wife used to be in forensics, and she loves watching true-crime programs and surgery shows. The thought of some of the acts in the Saw films nearly makes me retch. Yet I have no trouble with blood and gore in games -- I typically play with all of the gore settings at max. Have games desensitized you to blood and gore? -Jason


The other night I was watching some random TV show with my parents. My mother decided she wanted to watch one of those documentary shows about plastic surgery. I don't know why, because she hates the idea of plastic surgery, but she just settled on it this particular time.

I don't believe she understood exactly what was going to be showed during the course of the program, but we quickly found out it was going to be about the actual operations themselves, with closeups of the surgeries.

The first operation was a breast enhancement. (Who else saw that coming?) It focused in as the surgeon made the first incision and began to widen the hole; blood poured out, and you could clearly see the surrounding fatty tissue. It was quite disgusting, and my mom nearly got sick.

But I was completely unaffected. I watched calmly as the surgeon went about the job. I didn't feel the slightest twinge or need to look away. I wasn't shocked by any of what I saw.

Afterward, I asked myself why I wasn't affected. I quickly realized it was because I'd seen far worse in video games.

 

I've seen heads ripped off, guts splattered over walls, and limbs cut off -- all in digital form. This kind of gore's common in games. There're always enemies to defeat, and some games let you do it in incredibly violent ways.

I think this has led to me being desensitized to real gore and violence, too. It occurred to me that maybe I'm the only person that's been desensitized by games; maybe something in me just doesn't work as well as it should.

So I conducted a little experiment at school. After a bit of research the night before, I found some particularly gory pictures and videos on the Internet. I shrugged them off and decided to see if others had a similar reaction.

So at lunchtime I gathered a bunch of friends -- three gamers and three nongamers. I didn't tell them what they'd be viewing; I just wanted to see their reactions. So we gathered around one of the computers in the library, and mindful of teachers, I brought up the selection of pictures and videos that I'd found the night before.

Two of my friends turned white and looked away. Another dry-heaved a bit. They talked about how disgusting these images were and why I was showing them. These were the nongamers.

The gamers looked at the pictures calmly, asked what the point was, and laughed at how the others reacted. None of the gamers were affected in the same manner as the nongamers. They just took it in stride.

While not a scientific exploration of the issue, this at lease proved my point to myself -- that games can desensitize people to gore and violence. But then I thought that maybe it's just a trait of my generation of gamers, the generation that's grown up with 3D gaming. Games have always been realistic to us.

So how about you? The majority of you are older and remember games when they were simpler. Do you think that you've been somewhat desensitized to blood and gore, too? Or is the mixture of pop culture and gaming a bigger factor?

 
0
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (28)
Default_picture
September 23, 2009
For me it's completely different. I've played my fair share of violent games, but I just can't look at things like shows about plastic surgery. So I guess video games haven't really desensitized me.
Jason_wilson
September 23, 2009
@Brian I'm the same way. My wife LOVES surgery shows (she used to be in forensics), and I get woozy at the site of real blood (others, not mine, though). If I know it's fake, I'm OK. If it's real, I can't deal with it.
Lance_darnell
September 23, 2009
:D - I agree with Brian and Jason - I am also the same way. But my little Bro is 16 and nothing - and I mean nothing - bothers him. The only games he plays are Call of Duty 4, TF2, and Resident Evil 4, so you could say its video games, but more likely its just everyone is different. I love the fact that you tested the matter on your friends!
Default_picture
September 23, 2009
I've played many games filled with violent content, watched many movies with violent content, and seen many disgusting things on 4chan.

I can watch horror films and not blink an eye at the violence.

But, I could barely watch the surgery scene in Saw III. I didn't like how they SPOILER ALERT!!!! killed Hitler in Inglorious Basterds.

While I do feel desensitized to some violence I still find some things disturbing in different mediums of entertainment and in real life.
Default_picture
September 23, 2009
It's a good thing you didn't perform your test on me, Jason, and Lance Ultan, because we might have passed out.
Nick_with_grill
September 23, 2009
Nothing could desensitize me from those surgery shows, or the smell of vommit.
I think there is truth to games, much like television desensitizing us. But I think gore, or grotesque images are one thing, moral and emotional situations are another.. and maybe more effective.Thats a whole different topic.
Default_picture
October 04, 2009
Frankly, I've yet to see a realistic enough depiction of blood or bleeding in a video game. I'm thankful for this, because shows creep me the hell out.
Awesome deployment of the scientific method, btw.
Default_picture
October 04, 2009
TV \ Games there is a filter between you and (gore) . And you get used to it playing. So yes! Real life, in person, way different. If you're trying to save someone you don't think of the gore at the moment but later that night it comes back for you to ponder.
Default_picture
October 04, 2009
TV Shows like CSI make me cringe as I see guts being examined with up-close camera shots and slow-mo and all the epic music blaring as the gore montage progresses. When I play games like Gears of War and chainsaw someone, I'm down with it. I enjoy it.

I think it's because it's so fast-paced in games like that, that it just gets shrugged off because there are other things to think about. In movies like Saw, it's something that makes it so interesting to watch, and it does it in detail, so you will be thinking of the gore the whole time.

To me, I hate the sight of blood and gore that isn't digitalized.
Photo-3
October 04, 2009
I feel like I'm a wimp when it comes to blood and gore these days, but then again I don't really play violent games that much anymore.
Default_picture
October 04, 2009
IT hasn't.

Case in point: You show someone the AC30 game-play from COD4, and show them actual footage of an AC30 gun-cam. They both look about the same (Game mimicking life mimicking a game), yet people get visibly uncomfortable from seeing the real life footage, yet feel nothing watching the game footage. Our brain understands the difference.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
I'm kind of sick of this topic. The two are not related in any way. I have no issue with fake blood and guts because it's fake.

The same is not true of real blood and guts, or even super real looking fakes (like in Saw and Hostel). Those will make me sick to my stomach every time.

If your fine with both real gore and fake gore, then that is you. That has nothing to do with desensitizing for most people.
Default_picture
October 04, 2009
I would say it depends on the person as well. My sister is a surgical R.N. and sees blood and gore all the time for a living, but she hates and is disgusted by gore filled movies and games, so it can work the other way around.
Pshades-s
October 04, 2009
Not much of a spoiler warning up there, Timothy. I would have appreciated not knowing that.

Anyway, to get back on topic, I disagree with the premise at work here. I like how you tried to gather an informal group of people as test subjects, but there were probably a lot of other factors at work besides "gamer" and "non-gamer."

My tolerance for violence is not set in stone. Sometimes I can laugh it off when I know it is fake, other times I find it disturbing and unpleasant even when it's just a movie or a comic book. Real violence, frankly, is always ugly in my eyes.

Playing violent video games hasn't changed my perception of violence in any way outside of that particular medium, and even then it hasn't made me less sensitive, only less shocked when I see it.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
Hammering the point again, real life and video game gore differ vastly. I'll bludgeon zombies every which way in Dead Rising, but just the thought of Faces of Death makes me sick.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
Eh, I've never had a problem with blood. Even when I was little, like 5, I could watch surgeries and whatnot on TV.

But extreme violence does bother me sometimes in movies. Games generally don't disturb me. The gore is more stylized, in many cases. I also have a certain amount of control over my actions in a game. That control makes me more comfortable, whereas a movie can make me more nervous because I can't control what's going to happen next.

Check out Rebel FM Episode 31 if you want to here some more opinions on violence in games.
Brett_new_profile
October 05, 2009
For me, it's all about context: I can play ultra-violent video games or watch splatter comedies like Evil Dead and Dead Alive with glee. But I wouldn't touch the Saw franchise with a ten foot pole, and if you had shown me those graphic images I would've yelled at you for showing me such sick stuff.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
i think that /b/ has desensitized me more than any game ever could. that shit is twisted!
Img_0580
October 05, 2009
Wanting to be a forensic scientist desensitized me. I shadowed scientists at the Arkansas State Crime Lab and saw my fair share of horrific things. That and a local police officer ran a class called "shock treatment" where he showed delinquents and hopeful police officers the horrible deaths associated with drug use and culture.

I took from that a desire to make gore films.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
It feels like the point of /b/ is for the users to try and outdo each other so the new visitors will be utterly disgusted. Real life violence will revile me to no end. But videogame violence has never affected me. Except maybe to be amazed by the new and different ways of showing it. I agree with others. It's probably because we know going in, this ain't realistic.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
I have become desensitized to VIOLENT gore. Like gore in war movies, games, etc. However other types of gore still bother me like surgery and other medical gore. I don't get it.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
I think it's important to keep in mind that being desensitized to blood and gore is not necessarily a bad thing. If we were all freaked out by blood and gore, who would be our surgeons? How could soldiers haul their wounded comrades out of the line of fire? Maintaining a level head in a bloody situation could mean the difference between life and death for yourself and your loved ones.
Jayhenningsen
October 05, 2009
I used to work for a mortuary company. This desensitized me long before I began playing realistically violent games. Pro tip: When changing the height of the gurney, always make sure you lower the feet first.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
@David Matos

I'm same as you, I can watch say a Tarantino film, play a game like Condemned 2 so on and so forth and be fine yet put me in front of something that is clearly very realistic or actually real (cant stand those medical shows) and I just feel sick. Makes no sense to me either.
Lance_darnell
October 05, 2009
GO ULTAN!!!! Front fricking PAGE!!!
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
I certainly wouldn't say that games have sensitized things for us. That said, there are other factors to consider such as how much violence and mutilation is looked at on a daily basis per person. Though this is prevalent in video games, it's common in movies and some television shows, too.

As for myself, I can't watch any sort of surgery without getting uncomfortable. With games, I'm more lenient, but gore is still not something I'm entirely good with viewing.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
I don't mean to sound completely insensitive, but isn't kinda advantageous to be 'desensitized' to the sight of blood and gore?

Not to the point where you wouldn't care if you saw someone badly wounded and bleeding in real life, but instead, if you wouldn't let the sight of an injury 'freak you out' and were able to make yourself useful in aiding the injured person.

That being said, I think there's a big difference (for me at least) for seeing something on a screen and seeing it real life. Or being done to a real person. As someone already mentioned, there's a stark distinction between something from Faces of Death as opposed to something over the top in Gears of War.

I think the real danger of desensitivity lies in when we don't treat the consequences of dire actions in a realistic manner, when people really start to believe war is a playground, or murder is a casual action.

But please don't get me wrong, I love violent, over the top video games of all sorts, but I also understand it's just a game, and don't apply those ideals to reality.
Default_picture
October 05, 2009
Our reactions to violence must be prefaced by context. Only a very small minority finds little or no separation between fictional and true violence. The quality or realism affects the magnitude of the gore, but not necessarily our reaction to it.

I would say with the certainty of experience that most would find actual, even low quality footage of a man shot to death or a woman undergoing surgery more difficult to watch that the most realistic, HD portrayal of one fictional ninja skewering another highly-pressurized ninja. Knowing that gore is falsified removes our empathic reaction to it.

Seeing the mega-evil bad guy beheaded is fun. A human beheading is not.
You must log in to post a comment. Please register or Connect with Facebook if you do not have an account yet.