Separator
The Drama of NBA 2K11
Downtown-shot-square
Saturday, October 23, 2010
EDITOR'S NOTEfrom Jay Henningsen

I hardly ever play sports games, but I enjoyed this tale about how NBA 2K11 transcended the typical sports-game experience. Even if you're not a fan of sports games either, you should read what Devon has to say. It may change your opinion about this title.

Professional sports simulations are, by their nature, almost unable to move in the same direction as gaming as a whole. While Mass Effect, Uncharted, and Enslaved are free to push narrative forward, the nature of sports games forces them into a position of making their simulations incrementally more accurate year after year. By following along with the dramatic career of the most famous athlete ever to play the sport, 2K has managed to add a pinch of story into their main course of spot-on simulation.

I am certainly not a rabid sports fanatic. There was a time I was pretty obsessed with basketball, but that was many years ago. Nowadays, I'm one of those clueless folks who has never heard of the current superstars in any pro sport and doesn't even know which sports are in-season at any given time.

However, I have fond memories of my interest in basketball. If I take this thought a step further, I have fond memories of a time when I would buy and play several basketball videogames every single year. It started with the SNES version of Bulls vs. Blazers and the NBA Playoffs.

Old basketball games were kind of a bitch.

In the early '90s, your favorite team had better make the playoffs or else you wouldn't see them in that year's sports title. As far as the game was concerned, they didn't exist. Also, you wanted to avoid moving around too much with the ball or else you might incur the wrath of the overzealous refs in the form of a charging call.

Developers made incredible strides by the time I tired of playing. I must have quit sometime in the era of the PS2 and Xbox. While I enjoyed playing these games, they improved only incrementally each year. This, along with the fact that I no longer followed basketball, pushed me away.

 

Fast-forward about seven years. I came very close to picking up NBA 2K10 after seeing some stellar reviews. I figured it had been long enough since I played for me to notice some substantial improvements. The $20 price-point on PC also helped. However, I ended up putting that off because of my extensive backlog at the time.

By the time I was ready to buy, 2K had dropped some delicious info on their next game in the series: the cover athlete would be Michael Jordan. My interest in basketball had coincided almost perfectly with Jordan's storied career with the Chicago Bulls. This was no coincidence.

Jordan in NBA 2K11

As a result, I decided to stick it out for the next game. I was sure I would enjoy it, and the nostalgic draw of being able to play as Jordan was a great incentive to wait. After all, I had already waited more than half a decade.

I fired up the game and was immediately dumped into the shoes of the man himself — a young Jordan facing off against Magic Johnson and the Lakers. I listened to the commentary as the game began. I still count this as the aspect of basketball games most improved in my absence.

Jordan dunks on Divac

As I listened to them recount the events surrounding the game and what was at stake, it occurred to me that I was experiencing something I never had in a sports game before: drama. I was living out a story. The developers wrapped-up this intensity with the rules of basketball and tied it neatly with a nice physics-engine-shaped bow. At that moment, those mechanical improvements helped me to live out this unfolding drama which depicted actual historical events.

It was truly a revelation. I have yet to touch any aspect of the game other than the Jordan Challenges. Why would I want to? I can live out moments that were incredibly important to me when I witnessed them all those years ago. Not to mention I still have yet to complete all the challenges as they are surprisingly difficult. I’m sure that, once I do complete them, I will happily begin my own drama by drafting Jordan into the current league.

You may wonder what makes this any different from playing as your favorite current star in any sports game. In those games, you merely take your team through a fantasy season. That experience may also be enjoyable and certainly has its place, but it lacks one thing that makes the Jordan Challenges unique: context.

For example, one of the challenges is to score at least 55 points against the Knicks. At face value, this challenge is very shallow. The context is introduced by that brilliant and dynamic commentary I mentioned previously.

Before it starts, you can read about the circumstances surrounding that particular game. In different scenarios, you hear that Jordan is playing in his first outing since returning from retirement or the commentators mention articles from local newspapers. This detailed commentary continues throughout the course of the game.

These minor details make the scenarios feel much more real. Much like one of the many random objects littered around the worlds of Bethesda's RPGs, NBA 2K11 has an attention to detail you expect from a game driven by narrative. Fortunately for us, that's what this game is: a sports game driven by narrative.

*shrug*

I recognize much of this could be lost on someone without proper context. For one, if you didn't know these scenarios were based on actual games, the challenges would lose weight. The reason they are so dramatic is that they really happened! Each of those games -- and countless others -- are tiny little stories of triumph over adversity. These stories, when taken as a whole, make up a career whose equal is not yet on the horizon and one that no player will eclipse for years to come.

Almost every aspect of NBA 2K11 is stellar from the quick response to the deft transitional animations, but that's not the real draw of the game. It allows you to experience a level of drama and emotion that digs deep past the typical surface level provided by these games. You won't simply make the buzzer-beater to win the fantasy finals; you will, as Michael Jordan, make the game-winning shot against the Utah Jazz in 1997 to win his sixth and final NBA Championship in his last game as a Chicago Bull. It's specific details such as these that push NBA 2K11 from the starting five to the Hall of Fame.

[Thanks again go out to Bryan Harper for his help editing this piece.]

sdProfessional sports simulations are, by their nature, almost unable to move in the same direction as gaming as a whole. While Mass Effect, Uncharted, and Enslaved are free to push narrative forward, sports sims are forced into a position of making their simulations incrementally more accurate year after year. By following along with the dramatic career of the most famous athlete ever to play the sport, 2K has managed to add a pinch of story into their main course of spot-on simulation.
 
I am certainly not a rabid sports fanatic. There was a time I was pretty obsessed with basketball, but that was many years ago. Nowadays, I'm one of those clueless folks who has never heard of the current superstars in any pro sport and doesn't even know which sports are in season at any given time. 
 
However, I have fond memories of my interest in basketball. Going a step further, I have fond memories of a time when I would buy and play several basketball videogames every single year. It started with the SNES version of Bulls vs. Blazers and the NBA Playoffs. 
 
In the early 90s, your favorite team had better make the playoffs or else you wouldn't see them in that year's sports title. As far as the game was concerned, they didn't exist. Also, you wanted to avoid moving around too much with the ball or else you might incur the wrath of the overzealous refs in the form of a charging call.
 
Developers made incredible strides by the time I tired of playing. I must have quit sometime in the era of the PS2 and Xbox. Those games were a joy to play but improved only incrementally each year. This, along with the fact that I no longer followed basketball, pushed me away.
 
Fast forward about seven years. I came very close to picking up NBA 2K10 after seeing some stellar reviews. I figured it had been long enough since I played for me to notice some substantial improvements. The $20 price-point on PC also helped. I ended up putting that off because of my extensive backlog at the time.
 
By the time I was ready to buy, 2K had dropped some delicious info on their next game in the series: the cover athlete would be Michael Jordan. My interest in basketball had coincided almost perfectly with Jordan's storied career with the Chicago Bulls. This was no coincidence.
 
As a result, I decided to stick it out for the next game. I was sure I would enjoy it, and the nostalgic draw of being able to play as Jordan was a great incentive to wait. After all, I had already waited more than half a decade.
 
I fired up the game and was immediately dumped into the shoes of the man himself — a young Jordan facing off against Magic Johnson and the Lakers. I listened to the commentary as the game began. I still count this as the aspect of basketball games most improved in my absence.
 
As I listened to them recount the events surrounding the game and what was at stake, it occurred to me that I was experiencing something I never had in a sports game before: drama. I was living out a story. All this was wrapped in the rules of basketball and tied up neatly with a nice physics-engine-shaped bow, but, at that moment, those mechanical considerations were in service of letting me live out an unfolding drama based on actual historical events.
 
It was truly a revelation. I have yet to touch any aspect of the game other than the Jordan Challenges. Why would I want to? I can live out moments that were incredibly important to me when I witnessed them all those years ago. Not to mention I still have yet to complete all the challenges as they are surprisingly difficult. I’m sure that, once I do complete them, I will happily begin my own drama by drafting Jordan into the current league.
 
You may wonder what makes this any different from playing as your favorite current star in any sports game. In those games, you merely take your team through a fantasy season. That experience may also be enjoyable and certainly has its place, but it lacks one thing that makes the Jordan Challenges unique: context.
 
For example, one of the challenges is to score at least 55 points against the Knicks. At face value, this challenge is very shallow. The context is introduced by that brilliant and dynamic commentary I mentioned previously.
 
Before the game, you can read about the circumstances surrounding that particular game. In the case of the game in question, Jordan is playing in his first outing since returning from retirement. His skills after having been out for a year are unproven. This is reiterated by the commentators throughout the course of the game.
 
Other tidbits are interspersed to give still more context to the story unfolding. For instance, in a different game, an away game against the Cleveland Cavaliers, the courtside correspondent mentions that a local paper has run an article on the outstanding defense of Michael's match-up for the evening. 
 
This is just a minor detail which makes the scenario feel much more real. It's like one of the many random objects littered around the worlds of Bethesda's RPGs. It is an attention to detail you expect from a game driven by narrative. Fortunately for us, that's what this game is: a sports game driven by narrative.
 
I recognize much of this could be lost on someone without proper context. For one, if you didn't know these scenarios were based on actual games, the challenges would lose weight. The reason they are so dramatic is that they really happened! Each of those games and countless others are tiny little stories of triumph over adversity which, taken as a whole, make up a career whose equal is not yet on the horizon and will not be eclipsed for years to come.
 
Almost every aspect of NBA 2K11 is stellar from the quick response to the deft transitional animations moving your player from one move to another, but that's not the real draw of the game. It allows you to experience a level of drama and emotion that digs deep past the typical surface level provided by these games. You won't simply make the buzzer-beater to win the fantasy Finals; you will, as Michael Jordan, make the game-winning shot against the Utah Jazz in 1997 to win his sixth and final NBA Championship in his last game as a Chicago Bull. It's contextual details such as these that push NBA 2K11 from the starting five to the Hall of Fame.
 
3
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (8)
Downtown-shot-square
October 20, 2010


Jay: It's great to hear your feedback. I have a weird relationships with sports: I've always enjoyed video games based on sports I didn't necessarily enjoy (football, for one). This one sweetened the pot a bit by portraying a sport and player I have a history with. Having said all that, this is still the first sports game I have bought in many years... unless you count racing... which I don't. ;-)


Jayhenningsen
October 19, 2010


I'm not a fan of sports games, but this was a good read. While I'm not likely to purchase an NBA game any time soon, I can see the added appeal of all of the Jordan challenges. During the time I was growing up, he was THE player, and it's cool that they give you the chance to relive some of that magic.


Nick_hair
October 23, 2010


This game sounds so awesome. I love basketball, so I'll probably pick this up.



And this article is so good, it doesn't even need an editor's note to make the front page.


Jayhenningsen
October 23, 2010


Nick - Oops. That was my fault. Thanks for pointing it out.


5211_100857553261324_100000112393199_12455_5449490_n
October 23, 2010


I honestly haven't been interested in an NBA title in ...Well, how long ago was NBA Jam, again?



Anyways, this sounds totally radical!  Wouldn't mind playing it at all.


Nick_hair
October 23, 2010


Jay: Haha, no problem. I just didn't know if Devon was a new member of the staff or something.


Me_and_luke
October 23, 2010


Interesting article, Devon!  Although I'm a huge sports fanatic, I've never had much interest in playing sports games, especially basketball.  This sounds like a really cool twist on the "season" formula, and I might have to check it out.


Downtown-shot-square
October 24, 2010


Thanks to everyone for the kind comments. I'm not a new Bitmob staffer, but I am available for hire! ;-)


You must log in to post a comment. Please register or Connect with Facebook if you do not have an account yet.