Separator
The Question
Me
Wednesday, December 16, 2009

It sounds like an easy question, a question with an easy answer, a question that I most definitely have been asked before. “What is your favorite game?” On a social networking site, this sort of question is effortlessly side stepped. I can simply write the name of a series rather then a specific entry. No need to think about which Final Fantasy is best, when I can simply state that I like the “Final Fantasy series.”

I've noticed that with other mediums people are more generous, less conservative and more prepared to name off their top 5 films, books, albums, etc. Games though, for whatever reason are harder to make top ten lists of. Perhaps it's the same and I'm simply too entrenched in the gaming zeitgeist, that I believe we're unique in this regard.

In any case, I was unprepared to name off my favorite game, let alone games. What exactly should be considered, what qualities entitle one game to be ranked over another? In other mediums the lack of interaction make this a simpler ordeal. Anyone can turn on an album, download an mp3 and simply vibe to the music, they can play it for a friend and not worry about that friend's capability to appreciate the music. No anguish over controls or camera angles that may personally irritate them.

At first I attempted to make a list of categories in my mind that would be ranked high in perfect games.

-Fun Factor

-Accessibility

-Depth

-Exploration

-Etc

Then I would simply think about which games would have those categories ranked the highest. The longer I thought about the question the more difficult the answer had become. Each step in thought took me a step further from the answer. My friend gave me an hour to think, so I thought on this, this alone for thirty minutes. It was a helpful distraction during my run.

Then it hit me, the best games are the games that I think of while NOT thinking about games. While simply living my life. My answers came out pseudo-unexpectedly, but accurately.

-Dragon Warrior VII (Playstation One)

-Super Smash Brothers Melee (GameCube)

-Bioshock (360)

Lists will be dominating the gaming press sites ferociously this month and many of them will have similar looking lists. Top Tens will include most of these:

-Borderlands

-New Super Mario Brothers Wii

-Modern Warfare 2

-Assassin's creed 2

-Left 4 Dead 2

-Torchlight

-Dragon Age: Origins

-Halo: ODST

-Batman: Arkham Asylum

-Shadow Complex

As a consumer and follower of gaming press, I think it's easy to forgot how difficult it is to rate games, specifically in a top ten list where FPSs can go up against a traditional western RPG like Dragon Age. And this is only dealing with games that came out the same year. How does one contrast and rank games from any era and of any genre? There really isn't one method, but a variety of methods.

So I've come to ask, all of the gamers out there that have feared this question, one simple question, “What are your top 3 games of all time?” Lets not worry about cliche', unique or mainstream responses. No more excuses, remember this list can change whenever you want it to, but I think it's important to have a list loaded and ready to fire. Who knows, your answer may create an engaging conversation and make you realize that maybe your top 3 aren't good enough, or maybe, that you love them more then you imagined.

When it comes to my three I've realized that they each capture a particular moment in my life that it's no surprise that while simply living my life I'm reminded of these three, time and time again. They've captured something better then most games out there.

For now though, no justifications are needed, what are your top 3?

 
BITMOB'S SPONSOR
Adsense-placeholder
Comments (14)
Default_picture
December 16, 2009
I really like they way you think about your top three: games you think about when you're not thinking about games. As a result, I think my top-three are 1. Diablo II 2. The Czho Saga (which I count as one continuous game, but [i]6 Days a Sacrifice[/i] is my favorite) 3. Dragon Quest IV I've always been interested in story and games and my favorites seem to reflect that. Diablo II reflects a powerful story but doesn't shove it down your throat all the time. The Czho Saga is imho the best told horror story told through a game and the nested plots that get tied up in 6 Days a Stranger flow elegantly into one another (and it takes you by surprise). Dragon Quest IV has a wonderful before and after effect and stories that are rarely seen in games (A merchant seeking fortune, for example). Whenever I'm thinking about stories my mind tends to drift to these games and the stories that come with them. My list would be quite a bit different if I were including other kinds of games (Dungeons and Dragons would be on top, I think, and Magic: The Gathering a close second) simply for how my life has shaped itself around these games. The games in my top three above have done that as well, just not to such a great extent.
Default_picture
December 16, 2009
Porky Pig's Haunted Holiday (SNES) Ape Escape (PSOne) Mystical Ninja 64 (N64) My next two would look like this: Chester Cheetah: Wild Wild Quest (SNES) Beyond Good & Evil (GC)
Me
December 16, 2009
Maybe you'd be with me Toby, but Ape Escape needs a treatment like God of War, give us an Ape Escape collection. I'd love to replay those games updated and with Achievements/Trophies.
Default_picture
December 17, 2009
The Ape Escape collection for PSP is the only thing I want it for now.
Default_picture
December 17, 2009
I just wrote down the first three games that entered my head: Elder Scrolls: Morrowind (PC) Shadow of the Colossus (PS2) Bioshock (Xbox 360) If I think anymore I would never get any answer typed but I am definitely happy with this answer. Cool post Carlos 8)
Me
December 18, 2009
Cool, Thanks. I definitely tried getting into Morrowind, but after 10 straight hairs of playing it, I was done. I'm giving Western RPGs another shot with Mass Effect, digging it thus far.
Default_picture
December 20, 2009
I have a problem. I've never been able to pick my favorites of anything, be it movies, books, music or games. It's just not something my brain can handle. I could list all the games I've played for over 100 hours and still never finished because I was loving the experience so much but there's so many of those. I'll keep it like this. RPG: Xenogears (700+hrs), Fallout 3, Final Fantasy 12 FPS: Halo 2 mp, Team Fortress 2 mp, CoD4 mp 2D: Castlevania SotN, Mega Man 3, Worms World Party 3D: Mario 64, GTA3, Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker
Default_picture
December 20, 2009
My favorites are on the Commodore 64: Sid Meier's Pirates!, AD&D; Pool of Radiance, and Wasteland. I don't really think about them as much as more recent games though. I did play the somewhat recent remake of Pirates, and Pool of Radiance got a sequel in 2001 that I didn't touch. However, due to the massive amounts of Fallout 3 coverage, Wasteland has come to mind numerous times in the past year.
Me
December 20, 2009
You're so close Tom, c'mon you can narrow it down some more!
Default_picture
December 20, 2009
@Carlos That's the best I can do! Honest :-(
Me
December 20, 2009
hahaha, alright.
Franksmall
December 26, 2009
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Perfect Dark Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver I don't know if it is a bad thing that so many of my top titles are older. I could list a bunch of newer titles as well, but there are only a few I would be willing to call games that I know I could come back to at any point in the future and still enjoy. These three titles I listed have each been played many times over my life, and have never gotten old. Great post!
Default_picture
December 26, 2009
Here are my top three, no justifications supplied :P 3. Super Mario Galaxy 2. Ico 1. Okami
Me
December 30, 2009
Some pretty sweet lists. I wonder if everyone is still happy with theirs, I know I am. I spoke to a friend the other day about this, he can think of his top 2, but can never have a solid third. At least for more then a few days.

You must log in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.